9. Vacanasodhanavaṇṇanā
55-59.
Idāni vacanasodhanaṃ hoti .
Tattha yadetaṃ puggalo upalabbhatīti vacanaṃ , taṃ sodhetuṃ puggalo upalabbhati , upalabbhati puggaloti .
Pucchā sakavādissa .
Tassattho – yadetaṃ puggalo upalabbhatīti padadvayaṃ , taṃ ekatthaṃ vā bhaveyya nānatthaṃ vā .
Yadi tāva nānatthaṃ , yathā aññaṃ rūpaṃ , aññā vedanā , evaṃ añño puggalo , añño upalabbhatīti āpajjati .
Athekatthaṃ , yathā yaṃ cittaṃ taṃ mano , evaṃ sveva puggalo , so upalabbhatīti āpajjati .
Tena taṃ vadāmi ‘‘ yadi te yo puggalo , so upalabbhati , evaṃ sante yo yo upalabbhati , so so puggaloti āpajjati , kiṃ sampaṭicchasi etan ’’ ti ?
Tato puggalavādī yasmā puggalassa upalabbhataṃ
V0.120 icchati , na upalabbhamānānampi rūpādīnaṃ puggalabhāvaṃ , tasmā puggalo upalabbhati , upalabbhati ke hi ci puggalo ke hi ci na puggalotiādimāha .Tassattho – mama puggalo atthi puggaloti satthu vacanato upalabbhati .
Yo pana upalabbhati , na so sabbo puggalo , atha kho ke hi ci puggalo ke hi ci na puggaloti .
Tattha ko -kāratthe ke- kāro , hi- kāro ca nipātamatto .
Koci puggalo , koci na puggaloti ayaṃ panettha attho .
Idaṃ vuttaṃ hoti – puggalopi hi rūpādīsupi yo koci dhammo upalabbhatiyeva , tattha puggalova puggalo .
Rūpādīsu
P0.23 pana kocipi na puggaloti .Tato taṃ sakavādī āha – puggalo ke hi ci upalabbhati ke hi ci na upalabbhatīti .
Tassattho – puggalo upalabbhatīti padadvayassa atthato ekatte yadi upalabbhatīti anuññāto dhammo puggalato anaññopi koci puggalo koci na puggalo , puggalopi
M0.125 te koci upalabbhati , koci na upalabbhatīti āpajjati , kiṃ sampaṭicchasi etanti ?So puggalassa anupaladdhiṃ anicchanto na hevan ti paṭikkhipati .
Ito paraṃ ‘‘ ājānāhi niggahan ’’ tiādi sabbaṃ saṅkhittaṃ .
Vitthārato pana veditabbaṃ .
Puggalo saccikaṭṭhotiādīsupi eseva nayo .
Sabbāni hetāni upalabbhativevacanāneva , apica yasmā ‘‘ puggalo upalabbhatisaccikaṭṭhaparamatthenā ’’ ti ayaṃ puggalavādino paṭiññā , tasmāssa yatheva puggalo upalabbhatīti laddhi , evamevaṃ puggalo saccikaṭṭhotipi āpajjati .
Yā panassa puggalo atthīti laddhi , tassā vijjamānotivevacanameva , tasmā sabbānipetāni vacanāni sodhitāni .
60. Tattha yaṃ avasāne ‘‘ puggalo atthi , atthi na sabbo puggalo ’’ tiādi vuttaṃ , tatrāyamadhippāyo – yañhetaṃ paravādinā ‘‘ puggalo atthi , atthi kehici puggalo , kehici na puggalo ’’ ti vuttaṃ , taṃ yasmā atthato puggalo atthi , atthi na sabbo puggaloti ettakaṃ hoti , tasmā naṃ sakavādī sampaṭicchāpetvā idāni naṃ evaṃ anuyuñjati .
Tayā hi ‘‘ atthi puggalo attahitāya paṭipanno ’’ ti vacanamattaṃ nissāya ‘‘ puggalo atthī ’’ ti laddhi gahitā , yathā ca bhagavatā etaṃ vuttaṃ , tathā ‘‘ suññato lokaṃ avekkhassu , mogharājā , sadā sato ’’ tiādinā ( su . ni .1125) nayena ‘‘ natthī ’’ tipi vuttaṃ , tasmā yatheva te ‘‘ puggalo atthi , atthi na sabbo puggalo ’’ ti laddhi , tathā puggalo natthi , natthi na sabbo puggalotipi āpajjati , kiṃ etaṃ sampaṭicchasīti ?
Atha naṃ asampaṭicchanto na hevāti paṭikkhipati .
Sesamettha niggahādividhānaṃ vuttanayeneva veditabbanti .
Vacanasodhanavaṇṇanā niṭṭhitā .