Word-by-word (English):
ye dhammā those dhammas/which dhammas;
sampayogato by way of association/conjunction;
pavattena occurring/existing;
hetunā with a root-cause (hetu);
saha together with;
vattanti they occur/proceed;
iti thus/because;
te dhammā those dhammas;
sahetukā "with-root-cause," i.e., accompanied by a hetu
Readable English:
Because those dhammas occur together with a hetu (root-cause) that is present through association (sampayoga), those dhammas are called sahetukā — "possessing a root-cause."
逐词中文:
ye dhammā 那些法;
sampayogato 通过相应(结合);
pavattena 生起、存在的;
hetunā 与因(根因);
saha 一起;
vattanti 它们生起;
iti 因此;
te dhammā 那些法;
sahetukā 有因的
流畅中文:
因为那些法与通过相应而存在的因(根因)一同生起,所以那些法被称为有因法(sahetukā)。
Word-by-word (English):
etesaṃ of these (dhammas);
tatheva in that very same way (i.e., by association);
pavatto occurring/present;
hetu root-cause;
natthi does not exist;
iti thus/because;
te dhammā those dhammas;
ahetukā without a root-cause
Readable English:
Because for these dhammas, a hetu present in that very same way — through association — does not exist, those dhammas are called ahetukā — "without a root-cause."
逐词中文:
etesaṃ 对于这些(法);
tatheva 正是以那种方式(即通过相应);
pavatto 存在的;
hetu 因;
natthi 不存在;
iti 因此;
te dhammā 那些法;
ahetukā 无因的
流畅中文:
因为对于这些法,以同样方式(通过相应)存在的因并不存在,所以那些法被称为无因法(ahetukā)。
Word-by-word (English):
mūlaṭṭhena in the sense of "root"; hetu-saṅkhātā = reckoned/defined as hetu; In the Pāḷi it says "hetu-dhammā"; hetu, when explained in the general sense, means "cause/condition"; that "cause" being potentially understood as a "general cause", it is said "in the sense of root"; not a general cause, but a root-cause — that is the meaning; "mūla" (root) further means: just as the tap-root of trees makes the entire tree firm, stable, and flourishing, so too hetu is the foundation that makes the co-arisen (sahajāta) mind, mental factors, and material phenomena firm; thus the sub-commentary (ṭīkā) expresses the nature of mūla as "suppaṭiṭṭhita-bhāva-sādhana" (that which establishes firm existence); when greed (lobha) takes root with respect to an object, the mind, mental factors, and the material body too stand firm upon that object — reflect carefully on this.
Readable English:
"Reckoned as hetu in the sense of root." In the Pāḷi text, the term used is "hetu-dhammā." When hetu is explained in its general sense, it means simply "cause." But since this "cause" could be misunderstood as a "general cause," the commentary specifies "in the sense of root (mūlaṭṭhena)" — meaning not a general cause, but a root-cause. The term "mūla" (root) here refers to the foundation that makes the co-arisen mind, mental factors, and matter stable and firmly established — just as the tap-root makes an entire tree firm and flourishing. Therefore the sub-commentary defines the nature of mūla as "suppaṭiṭṭhita-bhāva-sādhana" — "that which produces a state of being firmly established." One should reflect on how, when greed takes root regarding an object, the mind, mental factors, and the physical body all become steadfastly fixed upon that object.
逐词中文:
mūlaṭṭhena 以"根"之义;hetu-saṅkhātā = 被称为因;巴利原典中有"因法"之语;hetu就一般义而言意为"原因/条件";由于此"原因"可能被误解为"一般原因",故说"以根义";非一般原因,乃根本原因;mūla(根)意指:正如树木的主根令整棵树稳固茁壮,因同样令俱生的心、心所、色法稳固;故注疏以suppaṭiṭṭhita-bhāva-sādhana(令稳固存在者)表达mūla之义;当贪对某所缘生根时,心、心所及色身亦稳固地驻于该所缘——请仔细思惟。
流畅中文:
"以根义被称为因。" 巴利原典中用的术语是"因法"(hetu-dhammā)。若就一般意义解释"因",则意为"原因"。但由于"原因"一词可能被误解为"一般原因",注疏特别指明"以根义"——即非一般原因,而是根本原因。此处"根"(mūla)是指令俱生心、心所与色法稳固住立的基础,正如树木的主根令整棵树稳固繁茂一样。因此,复注以"令稳固存在之义"(suppaṭiṭṭhita-bhāva-sādhana)阐明"根"的本质。当贪对某所缘生根时,心、心所乃至色身皆稳固地驻于该所缘,应当用心思惟此义。
Word-by-word (English):
ye dhammā those dhammas / which dhammas;
ekuppādāditāya by virtue of arising-together (ekuppāda) and so on;
hetunā with a hetu;
sampayuttā associated/conjoined;
[Note: since ekuppādāditāya is already a qualifying adjective (visesana), the grammatical sense of sampayutta need not be derived separately];
iti thus/because;
te dhammā those dhammas;
hetusampayuttā associated with a root-cause
Readable English:
Because those dhammas are conjoined with a hetu by virtue of arising-together (ekuppāda) and so forth [since ekuppādāditāya already serves as the qualifying term, sampayutta does not require a separate grammatical derivation], those dhammas are called hetusampayuttā — "associated with a root-cause."
逐词中文:
ye dhammā 那些法;
ekuppādāditāya 凭借俱生(同时生起)等;
hetunā 与因;
sampayuttā 相应、结合;(注:因ekuppādāditāya已作限定语,sampayutta无需另行作语法推导);
iti 因此;
te dhammā 那些法;
hetusampayuttā 与因相应的
流畅中文:
因为那些法凭借俱生等方式与因相应(由于ekuppādāditāya已作限定,sampayutta无需另行作语法解析),所以那些法被称为与因相应法(hetusampayuttā)。
Word-by-word (English):
ye dhammā those dhammas;
hetunā from/with a hetu;
vippayuttā dissociated, not conjoined (by arising-together and so forth);
[Note: since there is no saṃ-prefix, do not add "equally/evenly"];
iti thus/because;
te dhammā those dhammas;
hetuvippayuttā dissociated from a root-cause
Readable English:
Because those dhammas are not conjoined with a hetu through arising-together and so forth [since there is no prefix saṃ- here, "equally" is not to be added in the derivation], those dhammas are called hetuvippayuttā — "dissociated from a root-cause."
逐词中文:
ye dhammā 那些法;
hetunā 与因;
vippayuttā 不相应、分离(不通过俱生等方式);(注:因无saṃ前缀,故语义推导中不加"平等地");
iti 因此;
te dhammā 那些法;
hetuvippayuttā 与因不相应的
流畅中文:
因为那些法不通过俱生等方式与因相应(由于此处无saṃ前缀,语义推导中不加"平等地"),所以那些法被称为与因不相应法(hetuvippayuttā)。
Word-by-word (English):
dvinnampi of both;
imesaṃ dukānaṃ of these dyads (the sahetuka-dyad and the hetusampayutta-dyad);
atthato in terms of meaning;
nānattaṃ difference/distinction;
kiñcāpi natthi although there is none whatsoever;
pana but/however;
desanāvilāsena by the beauty/elegance of the teaching; (i.e., by the omniscient wisdom that makes the teaching splendid);
tathā in that way (by those categories: sahetukā dhammā, hetusampayuttā dhammā, etc.);
bujjhantānaṃ of those who can understand (those who can comprehend the sahetuka and hetusampayutta dhammas — not referring to understanding the Four Truths, but to comprehending these dhammas);
puggalānaṃ of persons;
ajjhāsayavasenavā also by the power of inclination/disposition;
dve two;
ime dukā these dyads;
Bhagavatā by the Blessed One;
vuttā have been taught/stated
Readable English:
Although, in terms of meaning, there is no real difference between these two dyads — the sahetuka-dyad and the hetusampayutta-dyad — nonetheless, the Blessed One taught these two dyads by virtue of the elegance of the teaching (i.e., the omniscient wisdom that makes the Dhamma splendid) and by virtue of the inclination of those persons who are able to understand (these dhammas) through those respective categories (sahetukā dhammā, hetusampayuttā dhammā, etc.). [This refers to persons' comprehension of those dhammas, not to the understanding of the Four Noble Truths.]
逐词中文:
dvinnampi 两者;
imesaṃ dukānaṃ 这两个二法组(有因二法组与因相应二法组);
atthato 就义理而言;
nānattaṃ 差别;
kiñcāpi natthi 虽然毫无差别;
pana 然而;
desanāvilāsena 凭借说法的庄严(即令教法庄严的一切智智);
tathā 以那些方式(有因法、因相应法等方式);
bujjhantānaṃ 能够了解的(能理解有因法、因相应法的);
puggalānaṃ 诸人的;
ajjhāsayavasenavā 也凭借意乐之力;
dve 二;
ime dukā 这两个二法组;
Bhagavatā 由世尊;
vuttā 已宣说
流畅中文:
虽然就义理而言,有因二法组与因相应二法组两者之间并无实质差别,然而世尊凭借说法的庄严(即令教法庄严的一切智智)以及能够通过各自范畴(有因法、因相应法等)来理解这些法的诸人的意乐,宣说了这两个二法组。〔此处指对这些法的理解,而非对四圣谛的证知。〕
Word-by-word (English):
tato from that (from the hetusampayutta-dyad);
paraṃ after/beyond;
paṭhamadukaṃ the first dyad (hetu-dyad);
dutiya tatiyehi with the second (sahetuka-dyad) and third (hetusampayutta-dyad);
saddhiṃ together with;
yojetvā having combined/yoked;
hetū, na hetūti ādīnaṃ beginning with hetū and na hetū ("roots" and "non-roots");
tesaṃ padānaṃ of those terms/words;
vasena by the power/force;
yathā sambhavato as is fitting/possible;
aparepi also other;
tayo three;
dukā dyads; (namely: hetu-sahetuka-dyad, hetu-hetusampayutta-dyad, nahetu-sahetuka-dyad);
vuttā have been taught
Readable English:
After that hetusampayutta-dyad, the Blessed One, having combined the first dyad (hetu-dyad) with the second (sahetuka-dyad) and the third (hetusampayutta-dyad), taught three further dyads as is fitting, by the force of those terms hetū, na hetū, etc. — namely: the hetu-sahetuka-dyad, the hetu-hetusampayutta-dyad, and the nahetu-sahetuka-dyad.
逐词中文:
tato 从那(因相应二法组)之后;
paraṃ 在……之后;
paṭhamadukaṃ 第一二法组(因二法组);
dutiya tatiyehi 与第二(有因二法组)和第三(因相应二法组);
saddhiṃ 一起;
yojetvā 结合后;
hetū, na hetūti ādīnaṃ 以"因"与"非因"等为首;
tesaṃ padānaṃ 那些词项的;
vasena 凭借……力;
yathā sambhavato 如适当的;
aparepi 另外也;
tayo 三;
dukā 二法组;
vuttā 已宣说
流畅中文:
在那个因相应二法组之后,世尊将第一二法组(因二法组)与第二(有因二法组)和第三(因相应二法组)相结合,凭借"因""非因"等词项之力,依照适当次序,宣说了另外三个二法组,即:因-有因二法组、因-因相应二法组、非因-有因二法组。
Word-by-word (English):
desanāvilāsena by the elegance of the teaching; vi- prefix + lasa-dhātu = (conveys the meaning of "being splendid/elegant"); vilāseti = makes splendid; vilāso = elegance; desanaṃ + vilāso = desanāvilāso; [Just as a tree in full bloom is beautiful, so the teaching, distinguishing between sahetuka and hetusampayutta, becomes elegant and splendid.]; that "desanāvilāsa" = the omniscient wisdom that knows, before teaching, how to present the co-arisen cittas as sahetukā or as hetusampayuttā; also the omniscient wisdom operative at the very moment of teaching; [Commentary: desanāvilāso = the wisdom knowing the manner of what is to be taught; and that too is omniscient wisdom — sub-commentary; "That wisdom thinking before the time of teaching, and that omniscient wisdom too" — Madhu-commentary.]
Readable English:
"By the elegance of the teaching (desanāvilāsa)." The prefix vi- together with the root lasa also carries the meaning of "being splendid." Vilāseti means "makes splendid"; vilāso "elegance"; desanaṃ + vilāso = desanāvilāso. [Just as a tree in full bloom is beautiful, so the teaching that distinguishes sahetuka from hetusampayutta is made splendid in the same way.] This "desanāvilāsa" refers to the omniscient wisdom that, even before teaching, already knows how the co-arisen mind-arisings can be presented either as sahetukā or as hetusampayuttā — the omniscient wisdom both prior to and at the very moment of teaching. [Sub-commentary: desanāvilāso = the wisdom knowing the manner of what is to be taught, and that is omniscient wisdom; Madhu-commentary: "The wisdom reflecting before the time of teaching, and that too is omniscient wisdom."]
逐词中文:
desanāvilāsena 凭借说法的庄严;*vi-*前缀+lasa词根 = 亦含"庄严"义;vilāseti = 使庄严;vilāso = 庄严;desanaṃ + vilāso = desanāvilāso;〔正如花开繁盛的树木美丽庄严,教法区分有因与因相应亦使教法庄严〕;此"说法庄严"= 在宣说之前已知如何将俱生心识宣说为有因法或因相应法的一切智智;亦指宣说当下运作的一切智智;〔复注:desanāvilāso = 了知所宣说方式的智;亦即一切智智;蜜注:宣说前思惟之智,亦即一切智智〕
流畅中文:
"凭借说法的庄严(desanāvilāsa)。" vi-前缀与词根lasa亦含"庄严"义。Vilāseti意为"使庄严",vilāso意为"庄严",desanaṃ + vilāso 即desanāvilāso。〔正如花开繁盛的树木美丽庄严,区分有因与因相应的教法同样庄严。〕此"说法庄严"是指一切智智——在宣说之前便已知晓如何将具有根因的心识宣说为"有因法"或"因相应法",以及宣说当下运作的一切智智。〔复注:说法庄严即了知所宣说方式的智,亦即一切智智;蜜注:宣说前思惟之智,亦即一切智智。〕
Word-by-word (English):
tattha therein / in those (three dyads); [The Pāḷi "tattha" is taken as the reference point];
hetū ceva dhammā sahetukā cā "(those dhammas that are) roots and also possessing-roots";
etaṃ this (phrase/category);
sambhavati yatheva just as it is fitting/possible (just as it is included in the Pāḷi text because it is fitting);
tathā likewise;
hetū ceva dhammā ahetukā cā "those dhammas that are roots and also without-roots";
idampi this also;
sambhavati is fitting [meaning: because it is fitting, it should be included]
Readable English:
Among those three dyads, just as the category "hetū ceva dhammā sahetukā cā" ("dhammas that are roots and also have roots") is fitting and is therefore included in the Pāḷi text, likewise the category "hetū ceva dhammā ahetukā cā" ("dhammas that are roots and also without roots") is also fitting and should equally be included.
逐词中文:
tattha 其中、在那(三个二法组)中;(巴利"tattha"作为参照);
hetū ceva dhammā sahetukā cā "既是因又是有因的法";
etaṃ 这(项目);
sambhavati yatheva 正如适当的(正如因适当而已纳入巴利原典);
tathā 同样;
hetū ceva dhammā ahetukā cā "既是因又是无因的法";
idampi 这也;sambhavati = 适当〔意即:因为适当,所以应当纳入〕
流畅中文:
在那三个二法组中,正如"既是因又是有因的法"(hetū ceva dhammā sahetukā cā)这一范畴因其适当而被纳入巴利原典,同样,"既是因又是无因的法"(hetū ceva dhammā ahetukā cā)这一范畴也是适当的,应当同样纳入。
Word-by-word (English):
ca and/moreover; not only that;
sahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū "dhammas that are possessed-of-roots but are not roots";
etaṃ this;
sambhavati yathā just as it is fitting;
tathā likewise;
ahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū "dhammas that are without-roots and are not roots";
idampi this also; sambhavati = is fitting [because it is fitting, it should be included]
Readable English:
And moreover, just as the category "sahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" ("dhammas that have roots but are not themselves roots") is fitting and is included in the Pāḷi, likewise the category "ahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" ("dhammas that are without roots and are not roots") is also fitting and should be included.
逐词中文:
ca 而且;不仅如此;
sahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū "是有因法但不是因的法";
etaṃ 这;
sambhavati yathā 正如适当的;
tathā 同样;
ahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū "是无因法且不是因的法";
idampi 这也;sambhavati = 适当〔因为适当,所以应当纳入〕
流畅中文:
而且,正如"是有因法但本身不是因的法"(sahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū)这一范畴因其适当而被纳入巴利原典,同样,"是无因法且本身不是因的法"(ahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū)这一范畴也是适当的,应当纳入。
Word-by-word (English):
hetusampayutta dukena with the hetusampayutta-dyad;
saddhiṃ together with;
yojanāyapi even in the combination/yoking;
esevanayo this very same method;
sambhavati applies/is fitting
Readable English:
The very same method applies when combining with the hetusampayutta-dyad as well.
逐词中文:
hetusampayutta dukena 与因相应二法组;
saddhiṃ 一起;
yojanāyapi 即使在结合中;
esevanayo 正是这同一方法;
sambhavati 适用
流畅中文:
在与因相应二法组结合时,也适用同一方法。
Word-by-word (English):
sambhavati arises together with / is compatible with / is possible; In grammatical treatises, a meaning that commonly associates with many (things) and thereby becomes general is called "sambhava"; when such sambhava exists, the entry of many meanings — "this meaning," "that meaning," etc. — is called "byabhicāra" (deviation/range); here too, the capacity to include other dyad-terms (the reason why other dyad-terms can enter) is called "sambhava"; [Commentary: sambhavo hi gahaṇassa kāraṇaṃ — "sambhava is the cause of inclusion"]; those dyads not directly present in the Pāḷi text but brought in and shown through the Aṭṭhakathā and Ṭīkā by reference to this sambhavati are called "sambhava-dukā" (compatible dyads / derivable dyads).
"Esevanayo" — Just as the term "hetū ceva dhammā hetusampayuttā cā" is fitting and has been included, so too "hetū ceva dhammā hetuvippayuttā cā" is fitting and should be included; just as "hetusampayuttā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" is fitting and has been included, so too "hetuvippayuttā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" is fitting and should be included.
Note: By this statement, note that two additional sambhava-dyads are obtained: the dyad "hetū ceva dhammā ahetukā cā; ahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" and the dyad "hetū ceva dhammā hetuvippayuttā cā; hetuvippayuttā ceva dhammā na ca hetū."
Readable English:
"Sambhavati" — In grammatical treatises, when a meaning becomes general through broad association, it is called "sambhava"; the resulting range of meanings that can enter is called "byabhicāra." Here, the capacity for other dyad-terms to be included is called "sambhava." [Commentary: "sambhava is the cause of inclusion."] Those dyads not found directly in the Pāḷi text but derivable through the Commentaries and Sub-commentaries on the basis of this sambhavati are called "sambhava-dyads."
"Esevanayo" — Just as the phrase "hetū ceva dhammā hetusampayuttā cā" is fitting and included, so too "hetū ceva dhammā hetuvippayuttā cā" is fitting and should be included; just as "hetusampayuttā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" is fitting and included, so too "hetuvippayuttā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" is fitting and should be included.
Note: By this statement, two additional sambhava-dyads are obtained: (1) the dyad of "hetū ceva dhammā ahetukā cā — ahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" and (2) the dyad of "hetū ceva dhammā hetuvippayuttā cā — hetuvippayuttā ceva dhammā na ca hetū."
逐词中文:
sambhavati 共生、可能、适当;在语法论典中,与许多事物相关联而变得普遍的意义称为"共生"(sambhava);当此共生存在时,各种意义的进入称为"通用性"(byabhicāra);此处,其他二法组词项得以纳入的能力(其他二法组词项能进入的原因)称为"共生";〔复注:sambhavo hi gahaṇassa kāraṇaṃ——"共生是摄取的原因"〕;凭借此"sambhavati",虽不直接出现于巴利原典,但通过注疏和复注引入展示的二法组,称为"共生二法组"(sambhava-dukā)。
"Esevanayo"——正如"既是因又是因相应的法"适当而已纳入,"既是因又是因不相应的法"同样适当应予纳入;正如"是因相应法但不是因"适当而已纳入,"是因不相应法但不是因"同样适当应予纳入。
注:由此语句可得另外两个共生二法组:(1)"既是因又是无因法;是无因法但不是因"之二法组;(2)"既是因又是因不相应法;是因不相应法但不是因"之二法组。
流畅中文:
"Sambhavati" — 在语法论典中,因与多种事物广泛关联而成为通义的意义称为"共生"(sambhava);由此产生的多种意义的进入范围称为"通用性"(byabhicāra)。此处,其他二法组词项得以被纳入的能力称为"共生"。〔复注:共生是摄取的原因。〕那些不直接出现于巴利原典,而是通过注疏和复注依据此"sambhavati"引入展示的二法组,称为"共生二法组"。
"正是此方法" — 正如"既是因又是因相应的法"适当而已被纳入,"既是因又是因不相应的法"同样适当,应予纳入;正如"是因相应法但本身不是因的法"适当而已被纳入,"是因不相应法但本身不是因的法"同样适当,应予纳入。
注释: 由此语句,又获得两个共生二法组:(1)"既是因又是无因法——是无因法但不是因"之二法组;(2)"既是因又是因不相应法——是因不相应法但不是因"之二法组。
Word-by-word (English):
ye dhammā those dhammas/which dhammas; sampayogato by way of association/conjunction; pavattena occurring/existing; hetunā with a root-cause (hetu); saha together with; vattanti they occur/proceed; iti thus/because; te dhammā those dhammas; sahetukā "with-root-cause," i.e., accompanied by a hetu
Readable English:
Because those dhammas occur together with a hetu (root-cause) that is present through association (sampayoga), those dhammas are called sahetukā — "possessing a root-cause."
逐词中文:
ye dhammā 那些法; sampayogato 通过相应(结合); pavattena 生起、存在的; hetunā 与因(根因); saha 一起; vattanti 它们生起; iti 因此; te dhammā 那些法; sahetukā 有因的
流畅中文:
因为那些法与通过相应而存在的因(根因)一同生起,所以那些法被称为有因法(sahetukā)。
Word-by-word (English):
etesaṃ of these (dhammas); tatheva in that very same way (i.e., by association); pavatto occurring/present; hetu root-cause; natthi does not exist; iti thus/because; te dhammā those dhammas; ahetukā without a root-cause
Readable English:
Because for these dhammas, a hetu present in that very same way — through association — does not exist, those dhammas are called ahetukā — "without a root-cause."
逐词中文:
etesaṃ 对于这些(法); tatheva 正是以那种方式(即通过相应); pavatto 存在的; hetu 因; natthi 不存在; iti 因此; te dhammā 那些法; ahetukā 无因的
流畅中文:
因为对于这些法,以同样方式(通过相应)存在的因并不存在,所以那些法被称为无因法(ahetukā)。
Word-by-word (English):
mūlaṭṭhena in the sense of "root"; hetu-saṅkhātā = reckoned/defined as hetu; In the Pāḷi it says "hetu-dhammā"; hetu, when explained in the general sense, means "cause/condition"; that "cause" being potentially understood as a "general cause", it is said "in the sense of root"; not a general cause, but a root-cause — that is the meaning; "mūla" (root) further means: just as the tap-root of trees makes the entire tree firm, stable, and flourishing, so too hetu is the foundation that makes the co-arisen (sahajāta) mind, mental factors, and material phenomena firm; thus the sub-commentary (ṭīkā) expresses the nature of mūla as "suppaṭiṭṭhita-bhāva-sādhana" (that which establishes firm existence); when greed (lobha) takes root with respect to an object, the mind, mental factors, and the material body too stand firm upon that object — reflect carefully on this.
Readable English:
"Reckoned as hetu in the sense of root." In the Pāḷi text, the term used is "hetu-dhammā." When hetu is explained in its general sense, it means simply "cause." But since this "cause" could be misunderstood as a "general cause," the commentary specifies "in the sense of root (mūlaṭṭhena)" — meaning not a general cause, but a root-cause. The term "mūla" (root) here refers to the foundation that makes the co-arisen mind, mental factors, and matter stable and firmly established — just as the tap-root makes an entire tree firm and flourishing. Therefore the sub-commentary defines the nature of mūla as "suppaṭiṭṭhita-bhāva-sādhana" — "that which produces a state of being firmly established." One should reflect on how, when greed takes root regarding an object, the mind, mental factors, and the physical body all become steadfastly fixed upon that object.
逐词中文:
mūlaṭṭhena 以"根"之义;hetu-saṅkhātā = 被称为因;巴利原典中有"因法"之语;hetu就一般义而言意为"原因/条件";由于此"原因"可能被误解为"一般原因",故说"以根义";非一般原因,乃根本原因;mūla(根)意指:正如树木的主根令整棵树稳固茁壮,因同样令俱生的心、心所、色法稳固;故注疏以suppaṭiṭṭhita-bhāva-sādhana(令稳固存在者)表达mūla之义;当贪对某所缘生根时,心、心所及色身亦稳固地驻于该所缘——请仔细思惟。
流畅中文:
"以根义被称为因。" 巴利原典中用的术语是"因法"(hetu-dhammā)。若就一般意义解释"因",则意为"原因"。但由于"原因"一词可能被误解为"一般原因",注疏特别指明"以根义"——即非一般原因,而是根本原因。此处"根"(mūla)是指令俱生心、心所与色法稳固住立的基础,正如树木的主根令整棵树稳固繁茂一样。因此,复注以"令稳固存在之义"(suppaṭiṭṭhita-bhāva-sādhana)阐明"根"的本质。当贪对某所缘生根时,心、心所乃至色身皆稳固地驻于该所缘,应当用心思惟此义。
Word-by-word (English):
ye dhammā those dhammas / which dhammas; ekuppādāditāya by virtue of arising-together (ekuppāda) and so on; hetunā with a hetu; sampayuttā associated/conjoined; [Note: since ekuppādāditāya is already a qualifying adjective (visesana), the grammatical sense of sampayutta need not be derived separately]; iti thus/because; te dhammā those dhammas; hetusampayuttā associated with a root-cause
Readable English:
Because those dhammas are conjoined with a hetu by virtue of arising-together (ekuppāda) and so forth [since ekuppādāditāya already serves as the qualifying term, sampayutta does not require a separate grammatical derivation], those dhammas are called hetusampayuttā — "associated with a root-cause."
逐词中文:
ye dhammā 那些法; ekuppādāditāya 凭借俱生(同时生起)等; hetunā 与因; sampayuttā 相应、结合;(注:因ekuppādāditāya已作限定语,sampayutta无需另行作语法推导); iti 因此; te dhammā 那些法; hetusampayuttā 与因相应的
流畅中文:
因为那些法凭借俱生等方式与因相应(由于ekuppādāditāya已作限定,sampayutta无需另行作语法解析),所以那些法被称为与因相应法(hetusampayuttā)。
Word-by-word (English):
ye dhammā those dhammas; hetunā from/with a hetu; vippayuttā dissociated, not conjoined (by arising-together and so forth); [Note: since there is no saṃ-prefix, do not add "equally/evenly"]; iti thus/because; te dhammā those dhammas; hetuvippayuttā dissociated from a root-cause
Readable English:
Because those dhammas are not conjoined with a hetu through arising-together and so forth [since there is no prefix saṃ- here, "equally" is not to be added in the derivation], those dhammas are called hetuvippayuttā — "dissociated from a root-cause."
逐词中文:
ye dhammā 那些法; hetunā 与因; vippayuttā 不相应、分离(不通过俱生等方式);(注:因无saṃ前缀,故语义推导中不加"平等地"); iti 因此; te dhammā 那些法; hetuvippayuttā 与因不相应的
流畅中文:
因为那些法不通过俱生等方式与因相应(由于此处无saṃ前缀,语义推导中不加"平等地"),所以那些法被称为与因不相应法(hetuvippayuttā)。
Word-by-word (English):
dvinnampi of both; imesaṃ dukānaṃ of these dyads (the sahetuka-dyad and the hetusampayutta-dyad); atthato in terms of meaning; nānattaṃ difference/distinction; kiñcāpi natthi although there is none whatsoever; pana but/however; desanāvilāsena by the beauty/elegance of the teaching; (i.e., by the omniscient wisdom that makes the teaching splendid); tathā in that way (by those categories: sahetukā dhammā, hetusampayuttā dhammā, etc.); bujjhantānaṃ of those who can understand (those who can comprehend the sahetuka and hetusampayutta dhammas — not referring to understanding the Four Truths, but to comprehending these dhammas); puggalānaṃ of persons; ajjhāsayavasenavā also by the power of inclination/disposition; dve two; ime dukā these dyads; Bhagavatā by the Blessed One; vuttā have been taught/stated
Readable English:
Although, in terms of meaning, there is no real difference between these two dyads — the sahetuka-dyad and the hetusampayutta-dyad — nonetheless, the Blessed One taught these two dyads by virtue of the elegance of the teaching (i.e., the omniscient wisdom that makes the Dhamma splendid) and by virtue of the inclination of those persons who are able to understand (these dhammas) through those respective categories (sahetukā dhammā, hetusampayuttā dhammā, etc.). [This refers to persons' comprehension of those dhammas, not to the understanding of the Four Noble Truths.]
逐词中文:
dvinnampi 两者; imesaṃ dukānaṃ 这两个二法组(有因二法组与因相应二法组); atthato 就义理而言; nānattaṃ 差别; kiñcāpi natthi 虽然毫无差别; pana 然而; desanāvilāsena 凭借说法的庄严(即令教法庄严的一切智智); tathā 以那些方式(有因法、因相应法等方式); bujjhantānaṃ 能够了解的(能理解有因法、因相应法的); puggalānaṃ 诸人的; ajjhāsayavasenavā 也凭借意乐之力; dve 二; ime dukā 这两个二法组; Bhagavatā 由世尊; vuttā 已宣说
流畅中文:
虽然就义理而言,有因二法组与因相应二法组两者之间并无实质差别,然而世尊凭借说法的庄严(即令教法庄严的一切智智)以及能够通过各自范畴(有因法、因相应法等)来理解这些法的诸人的意乐,宣说了这两个二法组。〔此处指对这些法的理解,而非对四圣谛的证知。〕
Word-by-word (English):
tato from that (from the hetusampayutta-dyad); paraṃ after/beyond; paṭhamadukaṃ the first dyad (hetu-dyad); dutiya tatiyehi with the second (sahetuka-dyad) and third (hetusampayutta-dyad); saddhiṃ together with; yojetvā having combined/yoked; hetū, na hetūti ādīnaṃ beginning with hetū and na hetū ("roots" and "non-roots"); tesaṃ padānaṃ of those terms/words; vasena by the power/force; yathā sambhavato as is fitting/possible; aparepi also other; tayo three; dukā dyads; (namely: hetu-sahetuka-dyad, hetu-hetusampayutta-dyad, nahetu-sahetuka-dyad); vuttā have been taught
Readable English:
After that hetusampayutta-dyad, the Blessed One, having combined the first dyad (hetu-dyad) with the second (sahetuka-dyad) and the third (hetusampayutta-dyad), taught three further dyads as is fitting, by the force of those terms hetū, na hetū, etc. — namely: the hetu-sahetuka-dyad, the hetu-hetusampayutta-dyad, and the nahetu-sahetuka-dyad.
逐词中文:
tato 从那(因相应二法组)之后; paraṃ 在……之后; paṭhamadukaṃ 第一二法组(因二法组); dutiya tatiyehi 与第二(有因二法组)和第三(因相应二法组); saddhiṃ 一起; yojetvā 结合后; hetū, na hetūti ādīnaṃ 以"因"与"非因"等为首; tesaṃ padānaṃ 那些词项的; vasena 凭借……力; yathā sambhavato 如适当的; aparepi 另外也; tayo 三; dukā 二法组; vuttā 已宣说
流畅中文:
在那个因相应二法组之后,世尊将第一二法组(因二法组)与第二(有因二法组)和第三(因相应二法组)相结合,凭借"因""非因"等词项之力,依照适当次序,宣说了另外三个二法组,即:因-有因二法组、因-因相应二法组、非因-有因二法组。
Word-by-word (English): desanāvilāsena by the elegance of the teaching; vi- prefix + lasa-dhātu = (conveys the meaning of "being splendid/elegant"); vilāseti = makes splendid; vilāso = elegance; desanaṃ + vilāso = desanāvilāso; [Just as a tree in full bloom is beautiful, so the teaching, distinguishing between sahetuka and hetusampayutta, becomes elegant and splendid.]; that "desanāvilāsa" = the omniscient wisdom that knows, before teaching, how to present the co-arisen cittas as sahetukā or as hetusampayuttā; also the omniscient wisdom operative at the very moment of teaching; [Commentary: desanāvilāso = the wisdom knowing the manner of what is to be taught; and that too is omniscient wisdom — sub-commentary; "That wisdom thinking before the time of teaching, and that omniscient wisdom too" — Madhu-commentary.]
Readable English:
"By the elegance of the teaching (desanāvilāsa)." The prefix vi- together with the root lasa also carries the meaning of "being splendid." Vilāseti means "makes splendid"; vilāso "elegance"; desanaṃ + vilāso = desanāvilāso. [Just as a tree in full bloom is beautiful, so the teaching that distinguishes sahetuka from hetusampayutta is made splendid in the same way.] This "desanāvilāsa" refers to the omniscient wisdom that, even before teaching, already knows how the co-arisen mind-arisings can be presented either as sahetukā or as hetusampayuttā — the omniscient wisdom both prior to and at the very moment of teaching. [Sub-commentary: desanāvilāso = the wisdom knowing the manner of what is to be taught, and that is omniscient wisdom; Madhu-commentary: "The wisdom reflecting before the time of teaching, and that too is omniscient wisdom."]
逐词中文:
desanāvilāsena 凭借说法的庄严;*vi-*前缀+lasa词根 = 亦含"庄严"义;vilāseti = 使庄严;vilāso = 庄严;desanaṃ + vilāso = desanāvilāso;〔正如花开繁盛的树木美丽庄严,教法区分有因与因相应亦使教法庄严〕;此"说法庄严"= 在宣说之前已知如何将俱生心识宣说为有因法或因相应法的一切智智;亦指宣说当下运作的一切智智;〔复注:desanāvilāso = 了知所宣说方式的智;亦即一切智智;蜜注:宣说前思惟之智,亦即一切智智〕
流畅中文:
"凭借说法的庄严(desanāvilāsa)。" vi-前缀与词根lasa亦含"庄严"义。Vilāseti意为"使庄严",vilāso意为"庄严",desanaṃ + vilāso 即desanāvilāso。〔正如花开繁盛的树木美丽庄严,区分有因与因相应的教法同样庄严。〕此"说法庄严"是指一切智智——在宣说之前便已知晓如何将具有根因的心识宣说为"有因法"或"因相应法",以及宣说当下运作的一切智智。〔复注:说法庄严即了知所宣说方式的智,亦即一切智智;蜜注:宣说前思惟之智,亦即一切智智。〕
Word-by-word (English):
tattha therein / in those (three dyads); [The Pāḷi "tattha" is taken as the reference point]; hetū ceva dhammā sahetukā cā "(those dhammas that are) roots and also possessing-roots"; etaṃ this (phrase/category); sambhavati yatheva just as it is fitting/possible (just as it is included in the Pāḷi text because it is fitting); tathā likewise; hetū ceva dhammā ahetukā cā "those dhammas that are roots and also without-roots"; idampi this also; sambhavati is fitting [meaning: because it is fitting, it should be included]
Readable English:
Among those three dyads, just as the category "hetū ceva dhammā sahetukā cā" ("dhammas that are roots and also have roots") is fitting and is therefore included in the Pāḷi text, likewise the category "hetū ceva dhammā ahetukā cā" ("dhammas that are roots and also without roots") is also fitting and should equally be included.
逐词中文:
tattha 其中、在那(三个二法组)中;(巴利"tattha"作为参照); hetū ceva dhammā sahetukā cā "既是因又是有因的法"; etaṃ 这(项目); sambhavati yatheva 正如适当的(正如因适当而已纳入巴利原典); tathā 同样; hetū ceva dhammā ahetukā cā "既是因又是无因的法"; idampi 这也;sambhavati = 适当〔意即:因为适当,所以应当纳入〕
流畅中文:
在那三个二法组中,正如"既是因又是有因的法"(hetū ceva dhammā sahetukā cā)这一范畴因其适当而被纳入巴利原典,同样,"既是因又是无因的法"(hetū ceva dhammā ahetukā cā)这一范畴也是适当的,应当同样纳入。
Word-by-word (English):
ca and/moreover; not only that; sahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū "dhammas that are possessed-of-roots but are not roots"; etaṃ this; sambhavati yathā just as it is fitting; tathā likewise; ahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū "dhammas that are without-roots and are not roots"; idampi this also; sambhavati = is fitting [because it is fitting, it should be included]
Readable English:
And moreover, just as the category "sahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" ("dhammas that have roots but are not themselves roots") is fitting and is included in the Pāḷi, likewise the category "ahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" ("dhammas that are without roots and are not roots") is also fitting and should be included.
逐词中文:
ca 而且;不仅如此; sahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū "是有因法但不是因的法"; etaṃ 这; sambhavati yathā 正如适当的; tathā 同样; ahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū "是无因法且不是因的法"; idampi 这也;sambhavati = 适当〔因为适当,所以应当纳入〕
流畅中文:
而且,正如"是有因法但本身不是因的法"(sahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū)这一范畴因其适当而被纳入巴利原典,同样,"是无因法且本身不是因的法"(ahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū)这一范畴也是适当的,应当纳入。
Word-by-word (English):
hetusampayutta dukena with the hetusampayutta-dyad; saddhiṃ together with; yojanāyapi even in the combination/yoking; esevanayo this very same method; sambhavati applies/is fitting
Readable English:
The very same method applies when combining with the hetusampayutta-dyad as well.
逐词中文:
hetusampayutta dukena 与因相应二法组; saddhiṃ 一起; yojanāyapi 即使在结合中; esevanayo 正是这同一方法; sambhavati 适用
流畅中文:
在与因相应二法组结合时,也适用同一方法。
Word-by-word (English):
sambhavati arises together with / is compatible with / is possible; In grammatical treatises, a meaning that commonly associates with many (things) and thereby becomes general is called "sambhava"; when such sambhava exists, the entry of many meanings — "this meaning," "that meaning," etc. — is called "byabhicāra" (deviation/range); here too, the capacity to include other dyad-terms (the reason why other dyad-terms can enter) is called "sambhava"; [Commentary: sambhavo hi gahaṇassa kāraṇaṃ — "sambhava is the cause of inclusion"]; those dyads not directly present in the Pāḷi text but brought in and shown through the Aṭṭhakathā and Ṭīkā by reference to this sambhavati are called "sambhava-dukā" (compatible dyads / derivable dyads). "Esevanayo" — Just as the term "hetū ceva dhammā hetusampayuttā cā" is fitting and has been included, so too "hetū ceva dhammā hetuvippayuttā cā" is fitting and should be included; just as "hetusampayuttā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" is fitting and has been included, so too "hetuvippayuttā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" is fitting and should be included. Note: By this statement, note that two additional sambhava-dyads are obtained: the dyad "hetū ceva dhammā ahetukā cā; ahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" and the dyad "hetū ceva dhammā hetuvippayuttā cā; hetuvippayuttā ceva dhammā na ca hetū."
Readable English:
"Sambhavati" — In grammatical treatises, when a meaning becomes general through broad association, it is called "sambhava"; the resulting range of meanings that can enter is called "byabhicāra." Here, the capacity for other dyad-terms to be included is called "sambhava." [Commentary: "sambhava is the cause of inclusion."] Those dyads not found directly in the Pāḷi text but derivable through the Commentaries and Sub-commentaries on the basis of this sambhavati are called "sambhava-dyads."
"Esevanayo" — Just as the phrase "hetū ceva dhammā hetusampayuttā cā" is fitting and included, so too "hetū ceva dhammā hetuvippayuttā cā" is fitting and should be included; just as "hetusampayuttā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" is fitting and included, so too "hetuvippayuttā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" is fitting and should be included.
Note: By this statement, two additional sambhava-dyads are obtained: (1) the dyad of "hetū ceva dhammā ahetukā cā — ahetukā ceva dhammā na ca hetū" and (2) the dyad of "hetū ceva dhammā hetuvippayuttā cā — hetuvippayuttā ceva dhammā na ca hetū."
逐词中文:
sambhavati 共生、可能、适当;在语法论典中,与许多事物相关联而变得普遍的意义称为"共生"(sambhava);当此共生存在时,各种意义的进入称为"通用性"(byabhicāra);此处,其他二法组词项得以纳入的能力(其他二法组词项能进入的原因)称为"共生";〔复注:sambhavo hi gahaṇassa kāraṇaṃ——"共生是摄取的原因"〕;凭借此"sambhavati",虽不直接出现于巴利原典,但通过注疏和复注引入展示的二法组,称为"共生二法组"(sambhava-dukā)。
"Esevanayo"——正如"既是因又是因相应的法"适当而已纳入,"既是因又是因不相应的法"同样适当应予纳入;正如"是因相应法但不是因"适当而已纳入,"是因不相应法但不是因"同样适当应予纳入。
注:由此语句可得另外两个共生二法组:(1)"既是因又是无因法;是无因法但不是因"之二法组;(2)"既是因又是因不相应法;是因不相应法但不是因"之二法组。
流畅中文:
"Sambhavati" — 在语法论典中,因与多种事物广泛关联而成为通义的意义称为"共生"(sambhava);由此产生的多种意义的进入范围称为"通用性"(byabhicāra)。此处,其他二法组词项得以被纳入的能力称为"共生"。〔复注:共生是摄取的原因。〕那些不直接出现于巴利原典,而是通过注疏和复注依据此"sambhavati"引入展示的二法组,称为"共生二法组"。
"正是此方法" — 正如"既是因又是因相应的法"适当而已被纳入,"既是因又是因不相应的法"同样适当,应予纳入;正如"是因相应法但本身不是因的法"适当而已被纳入,"是因不相应法但本身不是因的法"同样适当,应予纳入。
注释: 由此语句,又获得两个共生二法组:(1)"既是因又是无因法——是无因法但不是因"之二法组;(2)"既是因又是因不相应法——是因不相应法但不是因"之二法组。
Word-by-word (English):
tatra therein / in that hetu-gocha section; na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpīti "dhammas that are not roots, whether with-roots or without-roots"; siddhe being already complete/accomplished (i.e., already complete even without the kho pana particle); na hetū kho pana dhammāti "but indeed, dhammas that are not roots"; atirittaṃ superfluous / additional / beyond what was needed; yad etaṃ khopanāti padaṃ that very term/word "kho pana"; Bhagavatā by the Blessed One; vuttaṃ was stated/said; tassa of that (the kho pana term); vasena by virtue of / by means of; ayaṃ atirekattho this additional/surplus meaning; saṅgahito has been included / gathered in; iti thus; veditabbo should be understood
Readable English:
In the hetu-gocha section of the Pāḷi text, the meaning was already complete with the phrase "na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpīti" ("dhammas that are not roots, whether possessing roots or without roots") — even without the particle kho pana. Yet the Blessed One stated the additional word "kho pana" in "na hetū kho pana dhammāti." It should be understood that by virtue of that superfluous kho pana particle, an additional surplus meaning has been gathered in. [As the grammatical principle states: "where there is a surplus particle, there is a surplus meaning" — so because of the extra kho pana, one should know there is an extra meaning.]
逐词中文:
tatra 在其中(在那因戈恰迦节); na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpīti "非因法,无论是有因或无因的"; siddhe 已完整(即使没有kho pana语粒也已完整); na hetū kho pana dhammāti "然而,非因法"; atirittaṃ 多余的、额外的; yad etaṃ khopanāti padaṃ 那个"kho pana"词项; Bhagavatā 由世尊; vuttaṃ 已说; tassa 那(kho pana词项)的; vasena 凭借; ayaṃ atirekattho 这额外的意义; saṅgahito 已被摄入; iti 如此; veditabbo 应当了知
流畅中文:
在巴利原典的因戈恰迦节中,"非因法,无论是有因或无因的"(na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpīti)这一表述即使没有kho pana语粒也已意义完整。然而世尊在"na hetū kho pana dhammāti"中加入了多余的"kho pana"一词。应当了知,凭借这个多余的kho pana语粒,一个额外的意义已被摄入其中。〔按语法准则:"有多余的语粒,则有多余的意义"——故因kho pana多余,应知有多余之义。〕
{Bhāsāṭīkā} - Word-by-word (English):
kathaṃ how; veditabbo should it be understood?; kevalaṃ merely / only (only — not including the dyads that will be shown under "aññepi aññathāpi"); na hetū dhammā … ahetukāpi icceva that it is fitting only for "na hetū dhammā … ahetukāpi"; sambhavati is fitting; na not (that is not all); atha kho but rather; aññepi other dyads too; aññāthāpi also through other modes of combination; sambhavanti are fitting; iti thus; (veditabbo) should be understood
Readable English:
How should this be understood? It should be understood not merely that the dyad "na hetū dhammā … ahetukāpi" alone is fitting — excluding the dyads to be shown under the principle "aññepi aññathāpi" (also other, also in other ways) — but rather that other dyads too are fitting through other modes of combination as well.
逐词中文:
kathaṃ 如何; veditabbo 应当了知?; kevalaṃ 仅仅(仅此,不包括将在"aññepi aññathāpi"下展示的二法组); na hetū dhammā … ahetukāpi icceva 仅"非因法……无因的"适当; sambhavati 适当; na 不(并非如此而已); atha kho 而是; aññepi 其他二法组也; aññāthāpi 也通过其他结合方式; sambhavanti 是适当的; iti 如此; (veditabbo) 应当了知
流畅中文:
应当如何了知呢?应当了知的不仅仅是"非因法……无因的"这一二法组(不含将在"亦有其他、亦以其他方式"原则下展示的二法组)适当,而是其他二法组也通过其他结合方式同样是适当的。
{Another Nissaya} - Word-by-word (English):
kevalaṃ merely / only; na hetū dhammā va only the na-hetu-dhammas (dhammas that are not roots); na sambhavanti do not [exclusively] apply / are not fitting [only for them]; sahetuka-ahetuka with-root / without-root; [i.e., the sahetuka-ahetuka mode of combination]; atha kho but rather; aññepi other (dhammas) too / dhammas other than na-hetu-dhammas, i.e., the hetu-dhammas as well; sambhavanti are fitting / applicable; sahetuka-ahetuka [mode] with the sahetuka-ahetuka mode of combination
Readable English:
It is not the case that only the na-hetu-dhammas (dhammas that are not roots) apply under the sahetuka-ahetuka mode of combination. Rather, other dhammas too — namely, the hetu-dhammas (dhammas that are roots) — are also fitting under the sahetuka-ahetuka mode of combination.
逐词中文:
kevalaṃ 仅仅; na hetū dhammā va 仅非因法; na sambhavanti 并非(仅)适用; sahetuka-ahetuka 有因-无因的方式; atha kho 而是; aññepi 其他(法)也,即非因法以外的因法; sambhavanti 适用; sahetuka-ahetuka [方式] 有因-无因的结合方式
流畅中文:
并非只有非因法(na-hetu-dhammas)才适用于有因-无因的结合方式。而是其他的法——即因法(hetu-dhammas)——也同样适用于有因-无因的结合方式。
Word-by-word (English):
kevalaṃ merely / only; na hetū dhammā the na-hetu-dhammas; sahetukā-ahetukā icceva only under the sahetuka-ahetuka mode (of combination); na sambhavanti are not fitting [only in that one mode]; atha kho but rather; aññathāpi also in another way / also through a different mode; [i.e., a mode other than sahetuka-ahetuka, namely:] hetusampayutta-hetuvippayutta the hetusampayutta-hetuvippayutta mode; sambhavanti are fitting; iti thus; ayaṃ atirekattho this surplus/additional meaning; saṅgahito has been gathered in / included; hoti is / becomes
Readable English:
Furthermore, the na-hetu-dhammas are not fitting only under the sahetuka-ahetuka mode of combination. Rather, they are also fitting under another mode — namely, the hetusampayutta-hetuvippayutta mode (associated with a root-cause or dissociated from a root-cause). It is in this way that the surplus meaning has been gathered in.
逐词中文:
kevalaṃ 仅仅; na hetū dhammā 非因法; sahetukā-ahetukā icceva 仅以有因-无因的方式; na sambhavanti 并非(仅)适用; atha kho 而是; aññathāpi 也以另一种方式; [即:] hetusampayutta-hetuvippayutta 与因相应-与因不相应的方式; sambhavanti 适用; iti 如此; ayaṃ atirekattho 这额外的意义; saṅgahito 已被摄入; hoti 是
流畅中文:
此外,非因法并非只适用于有因-无因的结合方式。而是也适用于另一种方式——即与因相应-与因不相应(hetusampayutta-hetuvippayutta)的结合方式。正是以这种方式,额外的意义已被摄入其中。
Word-by-word (English):
kathaṃ na kevalaṃ na hetū dhammā "How [is it that] not only the na-hetu-dhammas [are fitting]"; atha kho aññepi sahetukā ahetukā icceva = "but rather, other [dhammas] too [are fitting] only under sahetuka-ahetuka"; āsa kho aññathāpi = "[and] also in another way"; iti = thus; Aṭṭhakathā-pāḷi = the Commentary Pāḷi text; evaṃ rahi mhan mhon sai = should read thus [i.e., this is the correct reading]
Readable English:
Note. The correct reading of the Commentary Pāḷi text should be: "kathaṃ na kevalaṃ na hetū dhammā, atha kho aññepi sahetukā ahetukā icceva, āsa kho aññathāpi" — "How [is it that] not only the na-hetu-dhammas [are fitting under this mode], but other dhammas too [are fitting] only under the sahetuka-ahetuka [mode]; and also [they are fitting] in another way as well." This is the correct form of the Commentary Pāḷi.
逐词中文:
kathaṃ na kevalaṃ na hetū dhammā "如何不仅仅非因法"; atha kho aññepi sahetukā ahetukā icceva "而是其他(法)也仅以有因-无因方式"; āsa kho aññathāpi "也以另一种方式"; iti 如此; Aṭṭhakathā-pāḷi 注疏巴利文; 应当如此读才正确
流畅中文:
注记。 注疏巴利文的正确读法应为:"kathaṃ na kevalaṃ na hetū dhammā, atha kho aññepi sahetukā ahetukā icceva, āsa kho aññathāpi"——"如何不仅仅是非因法(适用于此方式),而是其他法也(仅以)有因-无因方式(适用);且也以另一种方式(适用)。"这才是注疏巴利文的正确文本。
Word-by-word (English):
tattha pana therein / in that context, moreover; aññepi aññathāpi iti by the words "also other, also in another way"; etesaṃ of these; visuṃ pavattiyā by separate/independent operation; dve dukā two dyads; dassitā have been shown; sayaṃ pavattiyā pana = but by its own/inherent operation; ayampi duko = this dyad also; veditabbo = should be known/understood; hetū ceva dhammā hetusampayuttāpi hetuvippayuttāpi = "dhammas that are roots, and also associated-with-root or dissociated-from-root"; iti = thus Readable English: Moreover, in that context, by the words "aññepi aññathāpi" ("also other, also in another way"), two dyads have been shown through separate/independent operation [of each word]. But through its own inherent operation, this dyad too should be understood: "hetū ceva dhammā hetusampayuttāpi hetuvippayuttāpi" — "dhammas that are roots, and are also either associated with a root-cause or dissociated from a root-cause." 逐词中文: tattha pana 在其中,此外;aññepi aññathāpi iti = 由"亦有其他、亦以其他方式"诸语;etesaṃ = 这些的;visuṃ pavattiyā = 通过各自独立的运作;dve dukā = 两个二法组;dassitā = 已被显示;sayaṃ pavattiyā pana = 但通过其自身固有的运作;ayampi duko = 这个二法组也;veditabbo = 应当了知;hetū ceva dhammā hetusampayuttāpi hetuvippayuttāpi = "既是因法又与因相应或与因不相应的法";iti = 如此 流畅中文: 此外,在那个语境中,通过"亦有其他、亦以其他方式"(aññepi aññathāpi)这些词语各自独立的运作,已显示出两个二法组。但通过其自身固有的运作,这个二法组也应当了知:"hetū ceva dhammā hetusampayuttāpi hetuvippayuttāpi"——"既是因法,又是与因相应或与因不相应的法。"
Word-by-word (English): ဤဋီကာပါဠိကို မြင်၍ seeing this Ṭīkā Pāḷi passage; ရှေ့ အထခေါ အညေပိကို ကွင်း၍ = bracketing/setting aside the earlier "atha kho aññepi"; နောက်၌ = afterward / in the subsequent [text]; အထခေါ အညေပိ အညထာပိ ဟူ၍ ရေးမှားတတ်သည် = one tends to write mistakenly "atha kho aññepi aññathāpi"; အထခေါ အညထာပိ သာ ရှိသင့်သည် = only "atha kho aññathāpi" should be there; ယခင်အနက်ကို ချဲ့လို့ရကား = because the previous meaning can be expanded; "ဣဒံ ဝုတ္တံ ဟောတိ" စသည်ကို မိန့်သော် = when [the text] states "this is what is meant," etc. Readable English: Upon seeing this Ṭīkā Pāḷi passage, one tends to make the mistake — by bracketing the earlier "atha kho aññepi" — of writing the subsequent text as "atha kho aññepi aññathāpi." However, it should be only "atha kho aññathāpi" [without aññepi]. This is because the previous meaning can be expanded [through the sentence frame] when the text states "idaṃ vuttaṃ hoti" ("this is what is meant") and so forth. 逐词中文: ဤဋီကာပါဠိကို မြင်၍ 看到这段复注巴利文;ရှေ့ အထခေါ အညေပိကို ကွင်း၍ = 将前面的"atha kho aññepi"括起(搁置);နောက်၌ = 在后面;အထခေါ အညေပိ အညထာပိ ဟူ၍ ရေးမှားတတ်သည် = 容易误写为"atha kho aññepi aññathāpi";အထခေါ အညထာပိ သာ ရှိသင့်သည် = 应当只有"atha kho aññathāpi";ယခင်အနက်ကို ချဲ့လို့ရကား = 因为前面的意义可以展开;"ဣဒံ ဝုတ္တံ ဟောတိ" စသည်ကို မိန့်သော် = 当(文本)说"此即所说之义"等时 流畅中文: 看到这段复注巴利文后,人们容易犯这样的错误:将前面的"atha kho aññepi"括起搁置,然后在后文误写为"atha kho aññepi aññathāpi"。然而,此处应当只有"atha kho aññathāpi"(不含aññepi)。这是因为,当文本以"idaṃ vuttaṃ hoti"("此即所说之义")等语句作铺垫时,前面的意义是可以展开阐释的。
Word-by-word (English):
idaṃ this; vuttaṃ hoti is what is meant / is what was said; kiṃ vuttaṃ hoti what is meant?; hi for / indeed (expands the explanation); na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpi the dyad "dhammas that are not roots, whether with-roots or without-roots"; sambhavati is fitting / applicable; yatheva just as; evaṃ likewise; hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpi the dyad "dhammas that are roots, whether with-roots or without-roots"; (sambhavati) is also fitting
Readable English:
What is the meaning of what was said? It means: just as the dyad "na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpi" ("dhammas that are not roots, whether with-roots or without-roots") is fitting, likewise the dyad "hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpi" ("dhammas that are roots, whether with-roots or without-roots") is also fitting.
逐词中文:
idaṃ 这; vuttaṃ hoti 是所说的意思; kiṃ vuttaṃ hoti 所说的是什么意思?; hi 因为(展开说明); na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpi "非因法,或有因或无因的"这一二法组; sambhavati 适当; yatheva 正如; evaṃ 同样; hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpi "因法,或有因或无因的"这一二法组; (sambhavati) 也适当
流畅中文:
所说的是什么意思呢?意思是:正如"非因法,或有因或无因的"(na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpi)这一二法组适当,同样,"因法,或有因或无因的"(hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpi)这一二法组也适当。
Word-by-word (English):
ca and / moreover; not only that; na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi the dyad "dhammas that are not roots, and with-roots" [The explanatory note continues: just as this dyad with kho pana removed is already in the Pāḷi text as the sixth dyad, and just as that dyad is fitting and has been included, likewise "hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpi" and "na hetū dhammā hetusampayuttāpi hetuvippayuttāpi" are also fitting.]
Readable English:
And moreover, not only that — the dyad "na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi" [The explanatory note clarifies: after setting up the sentence frame with "this is what is meant," the commentary expands with "for just as…" etc. The dyad "na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi" with kho pana removed is already the sixth dyad in the Pāḷi text; just as that dyad is fitting and included, so too the dyads "hetū dhammā sahetukāpi ahetukāpi" and "na hetū dhammā hetusampayuttāpi hetuvippayuttāpi" are also fitting.]
Note: By the statement above, note that in addition to the two sambhava-dyads shown earlier, two more atireka (surplus) dyads arising from the kho pana particle are obtained — making four additional dyads total according to the Commentary. Furthermore, the Sub-commentary, following the principle "aññepi aññathāpi," indicates that the dyad "hetū ceva dhammā hetusampayuttāpi" should also be known, as it arises from combining hetu with hetusampayutta and hetuvippayutta.
Word-by-word (English):
(sambhavati) is fitting; yathā just as; evaṃ likewise; na hetū dhammā hetusampayuttāpi hetuvippayuttāpi the dyad "dhammas that are not roots, whether associated with roots or dissociated from roots"; (sambhavati) is also fitting; iti thus; vuttaṃ hoti this is what is meant; iti thus; atirekattho the surplus/additional meaning; saṅgahito has been gathered in / included; iti thus; veditabbo should be understood; [The iti at the end closes the sentence and also accounts for one instance of iti in the text.]
Readable English:
Just as (the above dyads are fitting), likewise the dyad "na hetū dhammā hetusampayuttāpi hetuvippayuttāpi" ("dhammas that are not roots, whether associated with a root-cause or dissociated from a root-cause") is also fitting. This is what is meant. Thus, it should be understood that the surplus meaning has been gathered in by virtue of the superfluous kho pana particle. [The closing iti wraps up the sentence and accounts for the iti in the passage.]
逐词中文:
ca 而且;不仅如此; na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi "非因法,且有因的"这一二法组〔注疏说明:以"此即所说之义"作为语句铺垫后,以"如……"等展开说明;"非因法有因的"去除kho pana后即为巴利原典中第六二法组;正如该二法组适当而已纳入,"因法或有因或无因的"以及"非因法或与因相应或与因不相应的"也适当〕
流畅中文:
而且,不仅如此——"非因法,且有因的"(na hetū dhammā sahetukāpi)这一二法组〔注疏说明:以"此即所说之义"作为铺垫后展开阐释:去除kho pana后的"非因法有因的"即为巴利原典中已有的第六二法组;正如该二法组适当而已被纳入,"因法或有因或无因的"以及"非因法或与因相应或与因不相应的"这两个二法组也同样适当。〕
注释: 由上文可知,连同此前所示的两个共生二法组,再加上因kho pana语粒产生的两个额外二法组,共得注疏所说的四个额外二法组。此外,复注依据"亦有其他、亦以其他方式"的原则,指出将因与因相应、因不相应结合所得的"既是因法又与因相应的"二法组也应当了知。
逐词中文:
(sambhavati) 适当; yathā 如……; evaṃ 同样; na hetū dhammā hetusampayuttāpi hetuvippayuttāpi "非因法,或与因相应或与因不相应的"这一二法组; (sambhavati) 也适当; iti 如此; vuttaṃ hoti 此即所说之义; iti 如此; atirekattho 多余的、额外的意义; saṅgahito 已被摄入; iti 如此; veditabbo 应当了知; 〔结尾的iti收束句意,同时对应文中的一个iti〕
流畅中文:
正如(上述各二法组适当),同样,"非因法,或与因相应或与因不相应的"(na hetū dhammā hetusampayuttāpi hetuvippayuttāpi)这一二法组也适当。此即所说之义。因此,应当了知:凭借多余的kho pana语粒,这一额外的意义已被摄入其中。〔结尾的iti收束全句,同时对应文中的一个iti。〕
English Translation:
In the lesser intermediate dyads (cūḷantaradukā), the meaning should be understood as follows: those dhammas which arise together (vattanti) with a condition (paccaya) that brings their own [resultant] to completion (nipphādaka) — whether a condition simultaneous with the conditioned dhamma, such as hetu and sahajāta and so forth; or a condition not simultaneous with the conditioned dhamma, such as anantara and samanantara and so forth; or a condition free from temporal relation (kālavimutta), namely Nibbāna and concept (paññatti), designated as the ārammaṇa condition, the adhipati condition, and so forth — those dhammas are called sappaccayā (with-condition).
Chinese Translation:
在小中间对(cūḷantaradukā)中,其义应如此理解:那些法(dhammā)与能令自身(之果)圆满生起的缘(nipphādakapaccaya)共同生起(vattanti)——无论是与所缘生法同时的缘,如因缘(hetu)、俱生缘(sahajāta)等;还是与所缘生法不同时的缘,如无间缘(anantara)、等无间缘(samanantara)等;抑或是离时间关系的缘(kālavimutta),即涅槃与概念法(paññatti),被称为所缘缘(ārammaṇapaccaya)、增上缘(adhipatipaccaya)等——那些法便称为有缘(sappaccayā)。
English Translation:
Because there is no condition (paccaya) for these dhammas either at the moment of arising (uppāda) or at the moment of presence (ṭhiti), those dhammas are called appaccayā (without-condition).
"sappaccayā" — The definition is given as: "those which arise together with a condition are sappaccayā." As for "condition" — since it is desired to include both types, namely the generating cause (janaka) and the supporting cause (upaṭṭhambhaka), the qualifier "that which brings one's own [result] to completion" (attano nipphādakena) is applied. By nipphādaka, both types of condition are obtained: that which brings to completion in the manner of generating (janaka), and that which brings to completion in the manner of supporting (upaṭṭhambhaka). These conditions are described in the Ṭīkā as "a condition that is simultaneous (samānakāla), non-simultaneous (asamānakāla), and free from temporal relation (kālavimutta)." A simultaneous condition refers to the type of co-arising condition (sahajātapaccaya) such as hetu and sahajāta among the twenty-four conditions of the Paṭṭhāna. A non-simultaneous condition refers to certain past conditions such as anantara, as well as ārammaṇa and future conditions. A temporally free condition refers to Nibbāna and concept (paññatti) that fall within the ārammaṇa type.
"appaccayā" — The word etesaṃ should not be connected with uppādevā ṭhitiyaṃ vā but with paccayā. The resolution (viggaha) can be made without uppādevā ṭhitiyaṃ vā as: "there is no condition for these, therefore appaccayā." Therefore, know that uppādevā ṭhitiyaṃ vā is not the principal term (padhānapada) to be connected with etesaṃ. In the earlier nissaya commentary, however, because of concern that uppādevā ṭhitiyaṃ vā might be connected [with etesaṃ], instruction was given that etesaṃ should not be rendered with the genitive particle "၏" but with the dative "အား."
On the six-fold [analysis]: As for "condition" — it produces by way of two kinds: producing at the moment of arising, and producing at the moment of presence; and since there is no condition of both these two kinds [for unconditioned dhammas], the phrase uppādevā ṭhitiyaṃ vā paccayo is stated. Connecting this with uppāda and ṭhiti further: uppādapaccayo vā — conditions of the arising-moment type; ṭhitipaccayo vā — conditions of the presence-moment type; natthi — do not exist. This is the intended meaning to be understood.
Chinese Translation:
由于这些法在生起刹那(uppāda)或住立刹那(ṭhiti)皆无缘(paccaya),故那些法称为无缘(appaccayā)。
"有缘(sappaccayā)" — 定义作:"那些与缘共同生起者,即为有缘(sappaccayā)。"就"缘"而言——由于意在涵盖两类,即生起因(janaka)与支持因(upaṭṭhambhaka),故加限定语"令自身[果]圆满之因"(attano nipphādakena)。依"令圆满"(nipphādaka)一义,两类缘皆得摄入:以生起方式令圆满者,以及以支持方式令圆满者。《复注》(Ṭīkā)将这些缘描述为"同时之缘(samānakālapaccaya)、非同时之缘(asamānakālapaccaya)以及离时间关系之缘(kālavimuttapaccaya)"。同时之缘,指《发趣论》二十四缘中俱生缘类,如因缘(hetu)、俱生缘(sahajāta)等。非同时之缘,指某些过去缘如无间缘(anantara)等,以及所缘缘(ārammaṇa)和未来缘等。离时间关系之缘,指属于所缘缘类的涅槃与概念法(paññatti)。
"无缘(appaccayā)" — "etesaṃ"一词不应与"uppādevā ṭhitiyaṃ vā"相连,而应与"paccayā"相连。其分解(viggaha)可不含"uppādevā ṭhitiyaṃ vā"而作:"此等法无缘,故为无缘(appaccayā)。"因此,应知"uppādevā ṭhitiyaṃ vā"并非与"etesaṃ"相连的主要语词(padhānapada)。然而在早期的nissaya注释中,因顾虑"uppādevā ṭhitiyaṃ vā"可能被连接于此,故特别指示"etesaṃ"不应用属格助词"၏",而应用与格"အား"来表示。
关于六支分析: 就"缘"而言——它以两种方式产生作用:在生起刹那产生作用,以及在住立刹那产生作用;由于[无为法]不具备这两类缘,故说"uppādevā ṭhitiyaṃ vā paccayo"。进一步与生起和住立相连:uppādapaccayo vā——生起刹那类之缘;ṭhitipaccayo vā——住立刹那类之缘;natthi——不存在。此为应当理解的涵义。
Because conditions (paccayā) have come together (samagantvā) and made [these dhammas], those dhammas are called saṅkhatā (conditioned).
由于诸缘(paccayā)和合聚集(samagantvā)而造作[这些法],故那些法称为有为(saṅkhatā)。
Those dhammas which are not conditioned (saṅkhatā) — that is, which have not been made by conditions coming together — are called asaṅkhatā (unconditioned).
那些非经诸缘和合造作之法——即非有为(saṅkhatā)之法——称为无为(asaṅkhatā)。
Because these dhammas possess form (rūpa) — namely the form-base (rūpāyatana), or alternatively earth (pathavī) and so forth — in the sense that they cannot be separated out individually (avinibbhogavasena), those dhammas are called rūpino (material).
由于这些法具有色(rūpa)——即色处(rūpāyatana),或具有地(pathavī)等——以不可各别分离(avinibbhogavasena)的方式存在,故那些法称为有色(rūpino)。
Because these dhammas do not possess such form — that is, they lack the form-base (rūpāyatana), or alternatively earth (pathavī) and so forth — those dhammas are called arūpino (immaterial).
由于这些法不具有如是之色——即缺乏色处(rūpāyatana),或缺乏地(pathavī)等——故那些法称为无色(arūpino)。
English Translation:
Alternatively: that which has the characteristic of undergoing alteration (ruppana) is rūpa; because these dhammas possess that [alteration], they are called rūpino (material).
"samagantvā" — In the Madhū [subcommentary], samethi is explained as "conditions that proceed together (ekatā pavatttehi paccayehi)." The word is parsed as samaṃ + itehi, with samaṃ explained as "together (ekatā)" and ita as "having proceeded (pavatttehi)." However, it should be noted that when conditions such as kamma and so forth produce and arrange conditioned dhammas, they do not do so by all gathering together equally at once; rather, each condition arrives effectively and precisely on its own terms and performs its respective function. Therefore, rather than rendering samehi as "having arrived equally," it is more fitting to render it as "saṃ + itehi — having arrived well." Likewise, in this samagantvā, it is better to render it simply as "saṃ + āgantvā — having arrived well," meaning: arriving precisely so as to reach and accomplish the respective result. [The reason why a single dhamma is expressed in the plural has already been shown in the Ṭīkā.]
"rūpino" — The commentary (Aṭṭhakathā) offers two explanations. In both, the formation is that of a possessive taddhita suffix: "rūpaṃ etesaṃ atthīti rūpino" — "these have form, therefore rūpino." In the first explanation, rūpa refers to the form-base (rūpāyatana, the form-object); alternatively, it refers to form beginning with earth (pathavī) and so forth. Since one might ask "in what sense do they 'possess form'?", the qualifier "avinibbhogavasena" — "in the sense of being inseparable" — is supplied to assist. In every group of material phenomena (rūpakalāpa), the form-base or form beginning with earth and so forth is present in a way that cannot be separated out through analysis — this is what is meant by calling them rūpino. Because these dhammas possess that alteration (ruppana), they are called rūpino (material).
Chinese Translation:
另一解:具有变坏(ruppana)之相者,称为色(rūpa);由于这些法具有彼[变坏之相],故称为有色(rūpino)。
"samagantvā(和合聚集)" — 在《蜜》疏中,samethi 被解释为"共同运行的诸缘(ekatā pavatttehi paccayehi)"。该词拆分为 samaṃ + itehi,其中 samaṃ 解作"共同(ekatā)",ita 解作"已运行(pavatttehi)"。然而应当注意,当业等诸缘造作和安排有为法时,并非所有缘等量齐聚、共同运作;而是各缘各自精确有效地到位,各自完成其相应的功能。因此,与其将 samehi 译为"等量到达",不如译为"saṃ + itehi——善至(having arrived well)"更为妥当。同样,此处 samagantvā 也应译为"saṃ + āgantvā——善至",意谓精确到达以成就各自之果。[单一之法而以复数表达的原因,《复注》中已有说明。]
"rūpino(有色)" — 《义注》(Aṭṭhakathā)给出了两种解释。两种解释中均用领有性派生词(taddhita)格式:"rūpaṃ etesaṃ atthīti rūpino"——"此等法有色,故称 rūpino"。第一种解释中,rūpa 指色处(rūpāyatana,即色所缘);另一解,指以地(pathavī)等为首的色法。由于有人可能问"以何种意义而'具有色'?",故以限定语"avinibbhogavasena"——"以不可分离之义"——加以辅助说明。在每一色聚(rūpakalāpa)中,色处或以地等为首的色法,以无法通过分析而单独分离的方式存在其中——此即称为 rūpino 之义。 由于这些法具有彼变坏(ruppana),故称为有色(rūpino)。
English Translation:
Those dhammas which are not rūpino — that is, which do not undergo alteration (ruppana) — are called arūpino (immaterial).
Chinese Translation:
那些非有色(rūpino)之法——即不具变坏(ruppana)之法——称为无色(arūpino)。
English Translation:
Regarding the dyad-term "lokiyā dhammā": the round of existence (vaṭṭa) is called loka because of its nature of breaking apart and completely breaking apart — that is, by way of momentary cessation (khaṇika-bhaṅga) and by way of final dissolution at death (antima-cuti). Those dhammas which are bound up (niyuttā) within that loka — that is, within the round of existence so designated — by way of being included (pariyāpannabhāvena) within it, are therefore called lokiyā (mundane).
Note: The Madhū [subcommentary]'s Burmese rendering of lujjana-palujjanaṭṭhena as "by the meaning of breaking and arising" (pyat-tat phyat-tat) is quite inappropriate.
Chinese Translation:
关于对法术语"lokiyā dhammā(世间法)":轮回(vaṭṭa)被称为loka(世间),是因其具有破坏与彻底破坏之性——即以刹那坏灭(khaṇika-bhaṅga)之义,以及以死时最终灭没(antima-cuti)之义。那些以被摄入(pariyāpannabhāvena)之方式,而系属(niyuttā)于彼被称为loka之轮回中的法,故称为lokiyā(世间的)。
注:《蜜》疏将 lujjana-palujjanaṭṭhena 的缅文译为"以破坏与生起之义"(pyat-tat phyat-tat),此译极为不当。
English Translation:
Because [these dhammas] have transcended (uttiṇṇā) that loka — namely the three-plane round of existence (tebhūmakavaṭṭa) — they are called uttarā. [Those path-dhammas that are in the process of transcending are called uttarā in the sense of uttaranti — "they transcend"; those fruit-dhammas that have already transcended are called uttarā in the sense of uttariṃ su — "they have transcended."] Because they are not included (apariyāpannabhāvena) within the loka, and because they have transcended (uttarā) from loka — that is, from the three-plane round of existence — they are called lokuttarā (supramundane).
On the phrase "ruppanalakkhaṇaṃ vā": In the first explanation given earlier — "dhammas that possess the form-base (rūpāyatana)" — the form-base itself cannot be included among them; only the other dhammas apart from the form-base can be included. Since this leaves the form-base unaccounted for — an unfitting omission — the second explanation "ruppanalakkhaṇaṃ vā" is given. In this second explanation, since dhammas that have the nature of undergoing alteration (ruppana) are called rūpino, the form-base too can be included.
Note: Since the Ṭīkā also explains rūpa in the first explanation as referring to forms beginning with earth (pathavī) and so forth, one might ask whether any of these forms — earth and so forth — remains unaccounted for under the term rūpino. When earth and so forth are designated rūpa, none remains excluded from rūpino, because earth possesses water (āpo) and so forth, and water in turn possesses earth and so forth — thus all material phenomena can be included under rūpino. For example: just as in the term sahetuka ("with root"), greed possesses the root delusion, and delusion possesses the roots greed and hatred — so all roots can be included under sahetuka — so too here. (Anuṭīkā)
On "lokiyā": The definition "loke niyuttā lokiyā" — "those bound up in the world are lokiyā" — is intended to convey that the word is formed by the taddhita suffix -iya giving the sense of association. Since one might ask "why are they bound up in the world?", the qualifier "tasmiṃ pariyāpannabhāvena" is added — meaning: because they are included within that loka, they are said to be "bound up in the world." As for the word loka itself: deriving it through lujjanalakkhaṇa — "it breaks, it completely breaks, therefore it is loka" (lujjati palujjatīti loko) — one then takes the three-plane round of existence (mundane mind, mental factors, and matter) as its referent. The form is derived from the root luja with the suffix ṇa, beginning with ja first, then applying ca by the rule kagācajānaṃ, making ca — in accordance with the Dhātupāṭha entry luja — nāsane, and palujjati is explained as "it perishes in various ways and manners." In the earlier nissaya commentary, the distinction is drawn: lujjana — "perishing by way of momentary cessation (khaṇabhaṅga)"; palujjana — "completely perishing without remainder by way of the final death (antima-cuti)."
Chinese Translation:
由于[这些法]已超越(uttiṇṇā)彼loka——即三界轮回(tebhūmakavaṭṭa)——故称为uttarā。[正在超越中的道法,以"uttaranti——彼等超越"之义称为uttarā;已超越完毕的果法,以"uttariṃ su——彼等已超越"之义称为uttarā。]由于不被摄入(apariyāpannabhāvena)于loka之中,且已从loka——即三界轮回——中超越出来,故称为lokuttarā(出世间)。
关于"ruppanalakkhaṇaṃ vā": 在先前所给出的第一种解释——"具有色处(rūpāyatana)之法"——中,色处本身无法被纳入其中;只有色处以外的其他法才能被纳入。由于色处因此遗漏在外——此为不当的缺失——故给出第二种解释"ruppanalakkhaṇaṃ vā"。在此第二种解释中,由于凡具有变坏(ruppana)之性的法均称为rūpino,色处也可被纳入其中。
注: 由于《复注》在第一种解释中亦将rūpa解释为以地(pathavī)等为首的色法,故有人可能会问:这些色法——地等——中,是否有任何一种在rūpino一词下遗漏在外?当地等被称为rūpa时,没有任何一种被遗漏于rūpino之外,因为地具有水(āpo)等,水又具有地等——因此一切色法均可被纳入rūpino之下。例如:正如在"有因(sahetuka)"一词中,贪具有痴根,痴具有贪根和嗔根——故一切根均可纳入sahetuka之下——此处亦然。(附注)
关于"lokiyā": 定义"loke niyuttā lokiyā"——"系属于世间者为lokiyā"——意在表明该词由表示关联义的taddhita后缀*-iya构成。由于有人可能问"为何系属于世间?",故加限定语"tasmiṃ pariyāpannabhāvena"——意谓:因被摄入于彼loka之中,故称为"系属于世间"。至于loka一词本身:通过lujjanalakkhaṇa推导——"它破坏,它彻底破坏,故为loka*"(lujjati palujjatīti loko)——以三界轮回(世间心、心所及色法)为其所指。该词由词根luja加后缀ṇa构成,先以ja为首,再依规则kagācajānaṃ将ca改作ca——依《界论》条目"luja——nāsane",而palujjati被解释为"以种种方式彻底坏灭"。在早期的nissaya注释中,区分如下:lujjana——"以刹那坏灭(khaṇabhaṅga)方式而坏灭";palujjana——"以最终死亡(antima-cuti)方式无余彻底坏灭"。
As for "kenaci viññeyyā": among the consciousnesses beginning with eye-consciousness (cakkhuviññāṇa) and so forth, there exist dhammas that are cognizable (vijānitabbā) by any one (kecī ekena) — whether by eye-consciousness or by ear-consciousness.
关于"kenaci viññeyyā":在眼识(cakkhuviññāṇa)等诸识之中,存在可由任何一个(kecī ekena)——或眼识、或耳识——所了知(vijānitabbā)的法。
English Translation:
As for "na kenaci viññeyyā": there exist dhammas that are not cognizable by that very same one —
Madhū-Ṭīkā: The root luca is a single [root] but, by way of general exposition, conveys the two meanings of breaking (bhijjana) and arising (nibbattana). The Madhū-Ṭīkā explains: "In the world, although the root luca is one, by way of general exposition it teaches two meanings — breaking and arising." Following that interpretation, some render lujjana as "perishing" and palujjana as "arising." That explanation and rendering should be examined against the Mahāṭīkā on the Maggāmagga-ñāṇadassana-visuddhi passage: "palujjanattāyāti byādhiādikārehi bhijjanato vinaṭṭhanato." According to that Mahāṭīkā, palujjana is merely an elaboration of the meaning of lujjana. In order to show that there are various kinds of perishing — perishing through disease, perishing through death, and so on — the prefix pa- is added, and lujjana itself is thus shown as palujjana. For this reason, teachers do not favor the Madhū-Ṭīkā's explanation.
Note: If [the world] is called loka because it perishes, one might ask: "Should not supramundane (lokuttarā) consciousnesses also receive the name loka, since they too perish at the moment of dissolution?" The answer is: it is precisely those three-plane round-of-existence dhammas that ordinary people (puthujjanā) take to be "permanent — unchanging and stable." In order to counter that view, those three-plane round-of-existence dhammas alone are deliberately named "loka — the perishing ones." Supramundane dhammas are not the domain of ordinary people but are the objects of noble persons (ariyapuggalā) alone. Noble persons do not take those supramundane dhammas to be "permanent"; because no such view exists [regarding them], there is no occasion to speak of them as loka, and hence they cannot receive the name loka. [As the Ṭīkā states: "That which, by its going-nature, neither breaks nor completely breaks — that is not loka in that sense. Therefore, supramundane dhammas that are free from grasping have no loka-nature."]
On "kenaci cakkhuviññāṇena vā": In the dyad-term kenaci viññeyyā, the word kenaci is understood as referring to one or another among [the five sense-consciousnesses], and the word points to the consciousness that performs the act of cognizing, leaving aside [for the moment] which specific consciousness it is. Therefore, showing the specific form of kenaci, [the text] cites cakkhuviññāṇena vā as an example; the word vā here carries the sense of alternative (vikappanattho). Taking kenaci as referring to eye-consciousness excludes the other five consciousnesses beginning with ear-consciousness; taking it as ear-consciousness excludes the other five beginning with eye-consciousness. The word vā, showing the unstated alternatives, [implies] that ghāna-viññāṇa, jivhā-viññāṇa, kāya-viññāṇa, and mano-viññāṇa are also each to be taken as one or another consciousness under kenaci.
— whether by eye-consciousness or by ear-consciousness — those dhammas which are not cognizable (na vijānitabbā) also exist.
关于"na kenaci viññeyyā":存在不可由那同一个所了知的法——
《蜜》复注: luca 词根虽为一个,然依一般表述的方式,传达破坏(bhijjana)与生起(nibbattana)两种含义。《蜜》复注解释道:"在世间,luca 词根虽为一个,然依一般表述方式,宣说破坏与生起两种含义。"依此解释,有人将 lujjana 译为"坏灭",将 palujjana 译为"生起"。然而此解释与译法,应以《道非道智见清净》段落的《大复注》加以审察:"palujjanattāyāti byādhiādikārehi bhijjanato vinaṭṭhanato。"依该《大复注》,palujjana 不过是对 lujjana 含义的进一步阐发。为了表明坏灭有多种形式——因病而坏、因死而坏等等——故加前缀 pa-,以 palujjana 来阐发 lujjana 本身之义。因此,诸论师不赞同《蜜》复注的解释。
注: 若因"坏灭"而称为 loka(世间),则出世间(lokuttarā)诸心在坏灭刹那也会坏灭,故有人可能问:"它们是否也应获得 loka 之名?"答曰:正是那些三界轮回法,被凡夫(puthujjanā)执取为"常住——不变不灭、永恒存在"。为了对治此见,唯有那些三界轮回法被特意命名为"loka——坏灭之物"。出世间法并非凡夫的领域,而唯是圣者(ariyapuggalā)的所缘境。圣者不将那些出世间法执为"常住";由于不存在如此之见[关于出世间法],便无称之为 loka 的缘由,故不能获得 loka 之名。[如《复注》所言:"那以其行进之性而既不破坏亦不彻底破坏者——于彼义而言非为loka。因此,离执取之出世间法无有 loka 之性。"]
关于"kenaci cakkhuviññāṇena vā": 在对法术语 kenaci viññeyyā 中,kenaci 一词被理解为指[五种感官识中]某一个,该词指向执行了知动作的识,暂且搁置具体是哪一个识。因此,为显示 kenaci 的具体形式,[文本]举 cakkhuviññāṇena vā 为例;此处 vā 一词具有选择义(vikappanattho)。将 kenaci 取为眼识,则排除以耳识为首的其他五识;将其取为耳识,则排除以眼识为首的其他五识。vā 一词显示未明言的其他情形,[暗示]鼻识、舌识、身识、意识也各自作为 kenaci 下某一个识而被纳入。
——或眼识、或耳识——不可被了知(na vijānitabbā)的法也存在。
When this is so, because the two terms — the term "kenaci viññeyyā" and the term "na kenaci viññeyyā" — differ in meaning (attha-nānattato), a dyad (duka) is formed.
既然如此,由于"kenaci viññeyyā"与"na kenaci viññeyyā"这两个术语在含义上有所差别(attha-nānattato),便构成一个对(duka)。
"They flow and proceed from the eye… up to the mind" — this is the stated meaning.
[Note on kenaci viññeyya: According to one interpretation, one takes eye-consciousness; according to another interpretation, one must also take eye-consciousness. Under the reading "kenaci viññeyyā dhammā," eye-consciousness cognizes visible form as its object; under "na kenaci viññeyyā dhammā," eye-consciousness does not cognize sound, smell, taste, touch, and mental objects. Alternatively, if one takes ear-consciousness under kenaci, then under kenaci viññeyyā dhammā, ear-consciousness does not cognize visible form, smell, taste, touch, and mental objects. Thus, taking these interpretations into account, whatever the chosen reading, the commentary states: "Because the meanings of the first term and the second term differ, this is a dyad of different meanings (atthanānatthatoduka)."
Annotation: The sub-commentary master did not favour this commentary method. The crux of the divergence between the commentary and sub-commentary is this: the sub-commentary master takes the two sentences in the Niddesa Pāli as "one dyad," while the commentary master takes them as a single term. Furthermore, the sub-commentary master illustrates a difference in the subject (viññāṇa as agent), while the commentary master illustrates a difference in the object (viññātabba as patient).]
"Flow and proceed" (sandanti pavattanti): In order to indicate the meaning of the root sand (to flow) of the bhu conjugation class, savanti is explained through verbal root analysis as "flow from the eye…etc." The word sandana ("flowing") does not mean actual physical flowing like water running along — rather, in order to convey that it means "arising" in terms of mental phenomena, the text provides the paraphrase "pavattantīti vuttaṃ hoti" as an explanation of the intended meaning.
Indeed, this prefix ā- in āsava carries the meaning of "enclosing within" (antokaraṇa).
[Question: Do not kusala, abyākata, and other phenomena also flow and arise through the six doors, just as lobha, diṭṭhi, and moha do? Why then are only lobha, diṭṭhi, and moha called āsava? The answer is: just as foul matter oozes from a wound in a repulsive manner, lobha, diṭṭhi, and moha flow through the six doors in a repulsive manner — therefore the word āsava is a conventional term (rūḷhisadda) denoting those phenomena which flow and arise in such an impure, repulsive manner. That is why only lobha, diṭṭhi, and moha are called āsava.]
"Dhammato…pe…āsavā": Lobha, diṭṭhi, and moha can take all mundane phenomena as object, but cannot take supramundane phenomena as object — therefore the text says "dhammato yāva gotrabhu." In the path-process (maggavīthi), the path and fruition arise after gotrabhu — meaning the path and fruition cannot be taken as object. Even though bhavaṅga-consciousness and other mundane process-consciousnesses continue to arise in accordance with conditions after path and fruition, these bhavaṅga-consciousnesses and so forth are similar to the earlier bhavaṅga-consciousnesses — therefore, under the scope of "yāva gotrabhu," they are already included among the phenomena within gotrabhu.
"Yāva bhavagga": Those phenomena of lobha, diṭṭhi, and moha can arise up to the sphere called bhavagga, which is the Sphere of Neither-Perception-Nor-Non-Perception (nevasaññānāsaññāyatana) — therefore the text says "yāva bhavagga." In this savanti, the sub-commentary explains the root as "savantīti gacchanti" (they go), so note that it conveys the sense of "going." The phrase "ete…pe…pavattantīti attho" is the explanation of the intended meaning (adhippāyattha). The phrase "antokaraṇattho hi ayaṃ ākāro" is a reinforcing sentence (daḷhīkaraṇavākya) that confirms "antokaritvā." This meaning of antokaraṇa is precisely the sense of abhividhā and avadhī as shown in grammatical treatises.
Annotation: Although "yāva gotrabhu" mentions only gotrabhu by name, in higher path-processes it includes vodāna as well, and in the processes of fruition-attainment (phalasamāpatti), it includes the preliminary workings (parikamma). Therefore, in "yāva gotrabhu," gotrabhu should be taken as an illustrative example (upalakkhaṇa method). In the Madhū, it is stated as the "one-remainder method (ekasesa) and general exposition (sāmānyaniddesa)." [Gotrabhu-vacanena gotrabhu-vodāna-phalasamāpatti-purecarika-parikammāni vuttānīti veditabbāni. — Sub-commentary.]]
This sutta passage beginning "purimā bhikkhave…pe…avijjā nāhosi" [including passages such as "purimā bhikkhave koṭi na paññāyati bhavataṇhāya" — beginning with which the text should be understood]: "Monks, before this" (meaning: before such-and-such a king's reign, or before such-and-such a Buddha's dispensation; alternatively: the gotrabhu that precedes the first path-process is cited by way of illustration with "yāva gotrabhu" — the vodāna and parikamma in higher path-processes and in fruition-attainment processes are also included under that gotrabhu — therefore, in other processes too, the arising of the path and fruition phenomena after vodāna and parikamma, as well as the arising of nibbāna, are thereby already precluded from being the domain of the āsavā) — before that, ignorance did not arise. Therefore, the first boundary point (koṭi) of ignorance is not discerned.
"Cirapārivāsiyaṭṭhena": Parivasiyanti — parivasiyā: those things such as fermented liquor that are caused to remain stored repeatedly; [this is formed by] the root vas with the prefix pari, causative, ṇya-suffix; by the sandhi rule "parivasiyā yeva pārivasiyā." "Long and repeatedly stored" means things that have been steeped for a long time and fermented until strongly pungent — like the present-day method of brewing liquor. Because such things, having been long stored, become ancient and old, the sub-commentary explains the meaning as "purāṇabhāvo" ("the state of being old"). In this way, the word āsava is a conventional term (rūḷhisadda) conveying the meaning of cirapārivāsiya. The passage "lokasmiṃ hi…pe…vuccanti" is a logical reinforcing statement (yutti-daḷhī-vākya) confirming that this conventional usage is indeed so.
"Yadi ca…pe…arahanti": This is a probability-statement (sambhāvanāvākya) showing that, if things that are cirapārivāsiya are called āsava, then lobha, diṭṭhi, and moha — being far more ancient than any traditional liquor — are all the more worthy of being called āsava.
"Before, ignorance had not arisen" — and thereafter it began to arise, as the Pāli continues — therefore: the first boundary point, the beginning-limit (koṭi) of ignorance, is not discerned (na paññāyati).
The āsavā are not present (natthi) in those phenomena that arise in this way (i.e., without taking themselves as object) — therefore those are called anāsavā.
["Āyataṃ vā…pe…āsavā": In āsavā, the intended form is "āyatasava," with yata dropped, giving āsavā. Because it is intended that āyata here means "the suffering of saṃsāra," the meaning of āyata is explained as "saṃsāradukkhaṃ." The sub-commentary explains savanti as "phalanti" — the root phal conveys the sense of nipphatti (completion, production). The root su (dhātu) also conveys the sense of janana (giving rise to). These two senses — "giving rise to" and "producing/completing" — are essentially the same. Just as a plant produces fruit, lobha, diṭṭhi, and moha likewise produce and give rise to the fruit that is saṃsāric suffering.
Annotation: In the commentary, savanti is explained as pasavanti. The root su with the prefix pa also conveys the sense of phalati. Therefore, when analyzing the sutta term, the sub-commentary explained pasavati as "phalati." In an earlier nissaya, it was considered that the pa-prefixed su-root conveys the sense of "giving birth" (sūti), and so the meaning was given as "pasavanti — they give birth to the offspring that is saṃsāric suffering." Whether this reflects the commentary's intent and whether it accords with this sub-commentary explanation — consider carefully.]
"Attānaṃ…pe…sāsavā": When the text speaks of sahetuka (with-cause) phenomena, those phenomena are sampayutta (associated) with their cause — but here sāsava is not named by way of sampayutta. Rather, it is called sāsava because those phenomena arise together with the āsava phenomena that take themselves as their own object — in order to make this clear, the qualifier "attānaṃ ārammaṇaṃ katvā pavattehi" is added. The essential meaning is simply: "saha āsavehi ye vattantīti sāsavā" — those that occur together with the āsavā are sāsavā.]
Having arrived at (upagantā) the state of being an object (ārammaṇabhāva), by way of their connection with the fetters (saṃyojanasambandhanena), they are the benefit/advantage (hitā) of the fetters (saṃyojanānaṃ); therefore they are called saṃyojaniyā (that which favours/benefits the fetters). [Grammatical note: this is formed as a hita-taddhita derivative — saṃyojanānaṃ + hitā → saṃyojaniyā, with the suffix -ika, the ka being elided; alternatively the suffix could be -ika in another analysis; however, in the Mūla-ṭīkā it is said to be formed with the suffix -ṇika.]
Explanatory note (on saṃyojenti): The root yuja, belonging to the su-class (svādi) of roots, conveys the sense of "binding" (bandhana), and is therefore glossed as bandhanti ("they bind"). In the context of the round (vaṭṭa), "binding" means: just as an ox is yoked and tied to a cart, so these dhammas bind and fasten the person possessing fetters into the three rounds — this is the intended sense. To elaborate: persons who have not yet exhausted fetters such as sensual lust (kāmarāga), when they perform kamma, do not act merely functionally (kiriya) as Arahants do; rather, they leave a residual potency (satti) of kamma behind to yield results in the future. This very residue amounts to binding the person possessing fetters within the round of kamma (kammavaṭṭa). The causing of that result to be obtained amounts to binding within the round of result (vipākavaṭṭa). And because earlier fetter-defilements exist, later defilements arise from them, so it also amounts to binding within the round of defilements (kilesavaṭṭa). In short, the point is: "the fetter-dhammas are the causes/conditions for the three rounds." [Ṭīkā note: "By being conditions (paccaya) for the rounds of defilement, kamma, and result, they bind (saṃyojenti) therein."]
Bhāsāṭīkā:
In the Ganthagocchaka, the meaning should be understood thus. Those dhammas (ye dhammā) that exist (saṃvijjanti) in the mental continuum of whichever person (yassa): that person (taṃ), by the power of death and rebirth-linking (cutipaṭisandhivasena), they bind (ganthenti) and connect (ghaṭenti) within the three rounds (vaṭṭasmiṃ). For this reason, (those dhammas) are called ganthā ("ties").
Nissaya:
In the Ganthagocchaka, those dhammas (ye dhammā) that exist (saṃvijjanti) for whichever person (yassa puggalassa): that person (taṃ puggalaṃ), by the power of death and rebirth-linking (cutipaṭisandhivasena), they bind (ganthenti) within the round (vaṭṭasmiṃ), as with bonds and ties such as shackles. For that reason (iti tasmā), those dhammas are called ganthā.
Note: Because the Dhātumālā gives "gantha bandhane" with the second-series letter (the aspirated th), the aspirated form is the correct one. The form ghaṭṭenti does not occur in the Ṭīkā, Anuṭīkā, Madhu(sāra) and so on. It is a later insertion.
Nissaya:
Dhammas other than that gantha (tato aññe) are called noganthā, that is, dhammas other than the gantha-dhammas. The dhammas which… [the Burmese breaks off here with a dangling "yedhammā … ko"; the clause is incomplete in the source].
Bhāsāṭīkā:
By way of taking them as object (ārammaṇakaraṇavasena), the gantha-dhammas are bound (ganthitabbā) by the ganthas. For this reason they are called ganthanīyā. [The root is gantha with the suffix anīya, so let it read "ganthanīyā."]
Nissaya:
By way of taking them as object (ārammaṇakaraṇavasena), they are to be bound (ganthitabbā) by the ganthas. For that reason (iti tasmā), those dhammas are called ganthaniyā.
Bhāsāṭīkā:
The remainder should be construed (yojetabbaṃ) by the very method stated (vuttanayeneva) in the Hetugocchaka.
Nissaya:
The remainder should be construed (yojetabbaṃ) by the very method stated in the Hetugocchaka.
Bhāsāṭīkā:
(Continuing with ca:) here (idha), in this Ganthagocchaka, the remainder should be understood by the very method stated. Just as it should be known (yathā), so too (evaṃ), in the gocchakas after this Ganthagocchaka (ito paresupi), the arrangement remaining after what has been directly stated (vuttāvasesaṃ) should be known (veditabbaṃ) in each of those respective gocchakas (tattha tattha) by the very method stated (vuttanayeneva).
Adhivacanaṃ. Because an earlier defilement can be an increase or growth of a later fetter, doubt arises: "Is it included within the meaning of saṃyojaniya?" Hence the text says, "saṃyojanassa … pe … adhivacanaṃ." The word saṃyojaniya is a well-established conventional term (rūḷhi-word) for the objects of the fetters. That is the meaning.
Ganthenti. When the root gantha denotes tying, one cannot tie death (cuti) and rebirth-linking (paṭisandhi) so that they become one single thing. All that is possible is to connect them so that rebirth-linking arises immediately after death, with no gap. Therefore the meaning is explained as "ghaṭenti." The root ghaṭ, in the bhū-group and the cura-group, denotes saṅghāṭa (joining together). In the Rye Nissaya, however, this ghaṭenti is said to be a later insertion into the text.
Nissaya:
Continuing with ca: here, in this Ganthagocchaka, by the very method stated, it should be known (veditabbaṃ) as (yathā) it is to be understood. In the same way (evaṃ), in the gocchakas that follow this Ganthagocchaka (ito paresupi), the remaining wording after what has already been stated (vuttāvasesaṃ) should be known in each of those respective gocchakas (tattha tattha) by the very method stated.
Special difference between saṃyojana and gantha-yoga. That which binds like the cord tied to the foot of a crow released into the sky is called saṃyojana (fetter). It pulls back and draws in a being who goes far away, and does not let him escape from the round (vaṭṭa). Making a binding so firm that one cannot move or come apart, like shackles and the like, is called gantha.
(Another explanation:) Iron leg-fetters, foot-binding cords and rings hold together through their mutual joining, so they cannot be broken or separated. In the same way, making the round firmly and inseparably bound, without break, is called gantha.
Making something stick and cling like tree-resin is called yoga. This is the difference.
English:
In the ogha group, the meaning should be understood as follows: those dhammas that exist in the mental continuum of a given person strike that person down in the three rounds (vaṭṭa) themselves, oppress him, and make him sink. For this reason, those dhammas are called oghā (floods).
中文:
在暴流组(oghagocchaka)中,意思应当这样理解:这些法存在于某个人的相续中,就在三种轮转(vaṭṭa)里把他往下压、折磨他,使他沉没。因此,这些法称为暴流(oghā)。
(From the footnote later)
English:
Oghā: The word is made from the prefix ava plus the root han. The ava becomes o. It is formed the same way as paṭigha, by the rule “saṃhanaññāya vā ro gho.” The root han has two meanings, “harming” (hiṃsā) and “going” (gati). Here we take “harming.” The sense is that these states push beings down into the suffering of the round (vaṭṭa) and torment them there. Pushing someone down and tormenting them is like sinking them in water, so the commentary explains it as “osīdāpenti” (“they cause to sink”). The main point is that the word ogha means a current of water, a flood. An ordinary current pulls down the people it sweeps along. In the same way, greed and the other states in this group keep the beings in whom they dwell sunk in the three rounds.
中文:
暴流(Oghā):由前缀 ava 加词根 han 构成,ava 变为 o。它和 paṭigha 的构成方法相同,依据"saṃhanaññāya vā ro gho"这条规则。词根 han 有"伤害"(hiṃsā)和"行走"(gati)两个意思,这里取"伤害"。意思是:这些法把众生压到轮转之苦中,并在那里折磨他们。把人压下去折磨,就像使人沉入水中,所以义注解释为"osīdāpenti"(使沉没)。要点是:ogha 这个词的意思是"水流",也就是暴流。普通的水流会把被冲走的人拖下水;同样,贪等这些法也使它们所寄居的众生沉没在三轮转之中。
English:
Because they are overcome, with them taken as object, that is, because they are the dhammas that are to be overcome by the floods, they are called oghanīyā (those subject to the floods).
中文:
因为(暴流)以它们为所缘而越过它们,也就是说,它们是应被暴流所越过的法,所以称为可被暴流越过者(oghanīyā)。
English:
Only those dhammas that serve as objects of the floods should be understood as oghanīyā. [The word is meant to be analysed as “oghehi atikkamitabbāti oghanīyā”. The details have already been shown in the explanation of the Ṭīkā.]
中文:
只有作为暴流所缘的那些法,才应当知道是可被暴流越过者(oghanīyā)。[这个词的意思,是要把它分析为“oghehi atikkamitabbāti oghanīyā”(应被暴流所越过者,称为 oghanīyā)。详细解说已经在复注(Ṭīkā)的解释中说明了。]
English:
In the yoga group, the meaning should be understood as follows: those dhammas that yoke (beings) and bind them to the round (vaṭṭa) are, for this reason, called yogā (yokes).
中文:
在轭组(yogagocchaka)中,意思应当这样理解:这些法把(有情)系结、连接在轮转(vaṭṭa)里,因此称为轭(yogā)。
English:
The yoganīyā dhammas should be understood in the same way as the oghanīyā dhammas. [The word is analysed as “ārammaṇaṃ katvā yogehi atikkamitabbāti yoganīyā”. According to the Ṭīkā, it is analysed as “yogena niyuttā yoganiyā” and “yogānaṃ arahantīti yoganiyā”.]
中文:
可被轭系缚者(yoganīyā)的诸法,应当像可被暴流越过者(oghanīyā)那样去理解。[这个词分析为“ārammaṇaṃ katvā yogehi atikkamitabbāti yoganīyā”。按复注的说法,则分析为“yogena niyuttā yoganiyā”(与轭相连者,称为 yoganiyā)和“yogānaṃ arahantīti yoganiyā”(适合于轭者,称为 yoganiyā)。]
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】 English: In the hindrance cluster (nīvaraṇagocchaka), the meaning should be understood like this: Some states nīvaranti pariyonandhanti, that is, they wrap over and cover the mind. Because of this, those states are called nīvaraṇa, “hindrances.” 中文: 在盖组(nīvaraṇagocchaka)中,(其意义应这样理解:)有些法会 nīvaranti pariyonandhanti,也就是缠裹、覆盖心。因为这个缘故,这些法称为"盖"(nīvaraṇa)。 --- English: Pariyonandhanti: The root var with the prefix ni means “covering” (āvaraṇa). This follows the Dhātvatthasaṅgaha entry “bhūra āvaraṇe.” To wrap over (to cover) the mind simply means to block it off, so that wholesome states cannot arise together with it. So take pariyonandhanti as a statement of the intended meaning (adhippāyattha). In other places the word is also explained as “jhānādikaṃ nivārentīti nīvaraṇāni”: “they obstruct jhāna and so on, therefore they are hindrances.” [The Thomanidhi says: “the ni is lengthened.”] 中文: Pariyonandhanti:词根 var 加前缀 ni,表示"覆盖"(āvaraṇa),这是依据《界义摄》(Dhātvatthasaṅgaha)中"bhūra āvaraṇe"的条目。缠裹(覆盖)心,其实就是把心挡住,使善法不能与它相应生起。所以要把 pariyonandhanti 理解为"意趣义"(adhippāyattha)。在其他地方,这个词也解释为"jhānādikaṃ nivārentīti nīvaraṇāni":"障碍禅那等,所以称为盖。"[《Thomanidhi》说:"ni 要变长音。"]
【Nissaya နိဿယ】 English: In the hindrance cluster (nīvaraṇagocchaka): those states that nīvaranti pariyonandhanti the mind, that is, that shut off, cover and envelop it, the way a cataract film covers the eye-sensitivity (cakkhupasāda), are for that reason called nīvaraṇa, “hindrances.” 中文: 在盖组(nīvaraṇagocchaka)中:有些法会 nīvaranti pariyonandhanti 心,也就是像遮住眼净色(cakkhupasāda)的翳膜那样,把心封闭、覆盖、缠裹起来,因为这个缘故,这些法称为"盖"(nīvaraṇa)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】 English: Nīvaraṇiyā: The states that are nīvaraṇiya (favourable to the hindrances) should be understood in the same way as saṃyojaniyā. [It is analysed as “nīvaraṇānaṃ hitā nīvaraṇiyā”: “beneficial to the hindrances, therefore nīvaraṇiya.” The words nīvaraṇa and saṃyojana can be formed as kita words with the suffix yu. So nīvaraṇiyā and saṃyojaniyā can be formed in the usual way, by a taddhita in the sense of hita (“beneficial to”). With oghanīyā and yoganīyā, the Ṭīkā shows that forms like oghana and yogana could be made with the suffix yu. But such forms are rare, so these two words are formed instead with the suffix anīya, in the sense of atikkamitabba, “to be overpassed.”] 中文: 顺盖(nīvaraṇiyā):顺盖诸法应当像顺结(saṃyojaniyā)一样理解。 [分析为"nīvaraṇānaṃ hitā nīvaraṇiyā":"有益于(顺于)诸盖的,称为顺盖。"nīvaraṇa、saṃyojana 这两个词可以用 yu 词缀构成为 kita(动词派生)词,所以 nīvaraṇiyā、saṃyojaniyā 可以按照常规,用"hita(有益于)义的 taddhita"构成。至于 oghanīyā(顺暴流)、yoganīyā(顺轭),依疏钞的意思,虽然也可以用 yu 词缀构成 oghana、yogana 的形式,但这类形式很少见,所以改用 anīya 词缀,在"应被超越"(atikkamitabba)的意义上构成。]
【Nissaya နိဿယ】 English: Nīvaraṇīyā: the states favourable to the hindrances (nīvaraṇīya) should be understood in the same way as the states favourable to the fetters (saṃyojanīya). [Point to note: this refers to the analysis “ārammaṇabhāvaṃ upagantvā nīvaraṇasamāgame nīvaraṇānaṃ hitāti nīvaraṇīyā”: “by becoming their object, they are beneficial to the hindrances when they meet with the hindrances (i.e. when the hindrances arise), therefore they are nīvaraṇīya.” Read nī with a long vowel.] 中文: 顺盖(nīvaraṇīyā):顺盖诸法应当像顺结(saṃyojanīya)诸法一样理解。[注意:这是指"ārammaṇabhāvaṃ upagantvā nīvaraṇasamāgame nīvaraṇānaṃ hitāti nīvaraṇīyā"这一分析:"成为所缘,在与诸盖相会(即诸盖生起)时有益于诸盖,所以称为顺盖。"nī 要读长音。]
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
In the misapprehension cluster (parāmāsagocchaka), the meaning should be understood like this: Mental and material phenomena have a real characteristic of impermanence and so on. “Real” (yathābhūtaṃ) can mean either “as it actually exists” or “as it truly is.” [Here “and so on” (ādi) includes suffering, non-self and foulness.] Some states go beyond that real characteristic. They occur by way of “permanent” and so on. [Here “and so on” includes pleasant, self and beautiful.] They āmasanti: they stroke, handle and take hold of things. They do this parato, “as something other,” meaning as permanent and so on, which is other than impermanent and so on. Because of this, those states are called parāmāsa, “apprehension.”
中文:
在妄执组(parāmāsagocchaka)中,(其意义应这样理解:)名色诸法有无常等真实之相。"真实"(yathābhūtaṃ)可以指"确实存在的",也可以指"如其真实的"。[这里的"等"(ādi)包括苦、无我、不净。]有些法超越了这真实之相,以"常"等方式而转起。[这里的"等"包括乐、我、净。]它们 āmasanti,也就是抚触、执取诸法。它们是 parato("从别的方面")去执取的,也就是从常等相去执取,而常等相不同于无常等相。因为这个缘故,这些法称为"妄执"(parāmāsa)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English: In the misapprehension cluster (parāmāsagocchaka): those states that, [going beyond] the real characteristic of impermanence and so on that phenomena (sabhāvadhamma) truly have, occur [by way of “permanent” and so on], and stroke them parato, “as other”, that is, by way of an unreal nature such as permanence, other than the real nature such as impermanence, stroking them in a way that rejects their real nature: for that reason those states are called parāmāsā, “misapprehensions”.
Note: In this Nissaya the gloss of aniccādiākāraṃ is followed directly by pavattamānā, so the words atikkamitvā niccanti ādivasena (“going beyond … by way of ‘permanent’ and so on”) are not glossed separately. They are supplied in square brackets from the Pāli.
中文: 在妄执组(parāmāsagocchaka)中:有些法,[超越]诸法(sabhāvadhamma)所真实具有的无常等相,[以“常”等方式]而转起,并且 parato(从别的方面),也就是以不同于无常等真实性质的常等不真实性质,以否定真实性质的方式去抚触诸法,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 parāmāsā(妄执)。
注:这份 nissaya 在解释 aniccādiākāraṃ 之后直接接 pavattamānā,没有另外解释 atikkamitvā niccanti ādivasena(超越……以“常”等方式)这几个字,方括号中的内容是依巴利原文补上的。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
The misapprehending states take these phenomena as their object. In doing so, they stroke (apprehend) them in a wrong way, other than the right way. Because they are grasped like this, these phenomena are called parāmaṭṭhā, “the misapprehended.” [It is analysed as “āmasīyanteti āmaṭṭhā; parato āmaṭṭhā parāmaṭṭhā”: “they are stroked, therefore āmaṭṭha; stroked as other, therefore parāmaṭṭha.”]
中文:
诸妄执法以这些法为所缘,从异于正确的错误方式去抚触(执取)它们。因为被这样执取,这些法称为"所妄执"(parāmaṭṭhā)。 [分析为"āmasīyanteti āmaṭṭhā;parato āmaṭṭhā parāmaṭṭhā":"被抚触,所以称为 āmaṭṭha;从别的(错误的)方面被抚触,所以称为 parāmaṭṭha。"]
English:
Parāmāsā: Split the word as para + āmasa. It is analysed as “āmasantīti āmasā”: “they stroke, therefore āmasa.” [Āmasanti means sabhāvapaṭisedhena parimajjanti: they rub over things while rejecting their true nature. In the word “stroke,” the meaning is not just a light touch. It means grasping firmly and stubbornly, like rubbing something tightly and hard. (Ṭīkā)] The full analysis is “parato āmāsā parāmāsā”: “stroking as other, therefore parāmāsa.” The word para means “other, different.” That “other” is the wrong, which is other than the right. So the commentary first states the right characteristic with “yathābhūtaṃ aniccādiākāraṃ.” Then it shows the wrong characteristic, which para refers to, with “niccanti ādivasena.” “Vipariyāsaggāho parāmasanaṃ”: grasping things perversely, the reverse of the truth, is called parāmasana - misapprehending.
中文:
妄执(Parāmāsā):把这个词拆为 para + āmasa。分析为"āmasantīti āmasā":"抚触,所以称为 āmasa。" [āmasanti 的意思是 sabhāvapaṭisedhena parimajjanti:一面否定法的真实本性,一面去摩擦它们。"抚触"在这里不是轻轻碰一下,而是牢牢地、顽固地执取,就像用力紧紧地摩擦一样。(疏钞)] 完整的分析是"parato āmāsā parāmāsā":"从别的方面抚触,所以称为 parāmāsa。"para 的意思是"别的、不同的",这"别的"就是不同于正确的错误。所以义注先用"yathābhūtaṃ aniccādiākāraṃ"说出正确之相,再用"niccanti ādivasena"指出 para 所说的错误之相。"Vipariyāsaggāho parāmasanaṃ":颠倒地执取,也就是与真实相反地执取,称为 parāmasana(妄执)。
English:
Anuṭīkā: “Parato ti ettha na dhammasabhāvato aññathāmattaṃ paran ti adhippetaṃ.” In the word parato, para does not just mean something that differs from the true nature of the dhamma. “Atha kho tabbipariyāyo ti.” What para really means is the exact reverse of that true characteristic of impermanence and so on. That is why it is said: “parato ti niccādito”: “parato means as permanent and so on.”
中文:
随疏钞(Anuṭīkā):"Parato ti ettha na dhammasabhāvato aññathāmattaṃ paran ti adhippetaṃ。"在 parato 这个词中,para 并不只是指与法的真实本性有所不同。"Atha kho tabbipariyāyo ti。"para 真正的意思是与无常等真实之相完全相反。所以说:"parato ti niccādito":"parato 的意思就是常等。"
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English: Because they are stroked by the misapprehensions, by way of being made their object, that is, stroked by way of an unreal nature such as permanence, other than the real nature such as impermanence, they are called parāmaṭṭhā, “the misapprehended”.
中文: 因为它们被诸妄执作为所缘而抚触,也就是以不同于无常等真实性质的常等不真实性质而被抚触,所以称为 parāmaṭṭhā(所妄执)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
In the great intermediate dukas (mahantaraduka), the meaning should be understood like this: some states do not occur without taking an object; so they occur together with an object. Therefore those states are called sārammaṇā, “having an object”.
Note: That is: because they cannot occur unless they take an object (unless there is an object), they are called sārammaṇa.
中文:
在大中间二法(mahantaraduka)中,意义应这样理解:有些法不取所缘就不能生起,所以它们是与所缘一起生起的。因此这些法称为 sārammaṇā(有所缘的)。
注:意思是:因为不取所缘(没有所缘)就不能生起,所以称为 sārammaṇa(有所缘)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
In the great intermediate dukas: [some states] do not occur without taking an object, so they occur together with an object. For that reason those states are called sārammaṇā, “having an object”.
中文:
在大中间二法中:[有些法]不取所缘就不生起,所以与所缘一起生起。因为这个缘故,这些法称为 sārammaṇā(有所缘的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
These states have no object; therefore they are called anārammaṇā, “without an object”.
中文:
这些法没有所缘,所以称为 anārammaṇā(无所缘的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
These states have no object; for that reason they are called anārammaṇā, “without an object”.
中文:
这些法没有所缘,因为这个缘故,称为 anārammaṇā(无所缘的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
They are citta (consciousness) in the sense of cintana, “cognizing”; or else they are citta in the sense of vicitta, “variegated”.
Note: The analysis is “ārammaṇaṃ cintetīti cittaṃ”, “it cognizes an object, therefore citta”. Even though it is called cintana, “thinking”, this is not the thinking out of applied thought (vitakka); it is the taking hold of some object so as to get it. [The word citta, in the sense of “variegated”, is an underived stem (anipphanna pāṭipadika). How it is variegated will be shown at length in the explanation of “cittaṃ uppannaṃ”.]
中文:
从 cintana(认知)的意义上说,它们是 citta(心);或者,从 vicitta(种种、多样)的意义上说,它们是 citta。
注:分析为“ārammaṇaṃ cintetīti cittaṃ”:“认知所缘,所以称为心”。虽然叫做 cintana(思),但这不是寻(vitakka)那种思量,而是为了得到某个所缘而去取它。[表示“多样”意义的 citta 这个词,是非派生的词干(anipphanna pāṭipadika)。心如何多样,将在“cittaṃ uppannaṃ”(心生起)的解释中详细说明。]
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
They are called citta in the sense of cintana, that is, in the sense of knowing in a way that goes beyond merely taking an object. Or else they are called citta in the sense of vicitta, “variegated”, by way of class (jāti), plane (bhūmi), association (sampayoga) and so on.
中文:
从 cintana 的意义,也就是从超出单纯取所缘而能认知的意义上说,称为 citta(心)。或者,从 vicitta(种种、多样)的意义,即依种类(jāti)、地(bhūmi)、相应(sampayoga)等而多样的意义上说,称为 citta。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states are yoked to the mind (cetasi niyuttā) by way of non-dissociation (avippayoga), that is, by way of never being without association with it; therefore those states are called cetasikā, “mental factors”.
中文:
有些法以不离(avippayoga)的方式,即从不与它不相应的方式,系属于心(cetasi niyuttā),所以这些法称为 cetasikā(心所)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states are yoked to the mind by way of non-dissociation, that is, by being associated with it inseparably; for that reason those states are called cetasikā, “mental factors”.
中文:
有些法以不离的方式,即与心不分不离地相应,系属于心,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 cetasikā(心所)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states, by coming into a state of being without distinction (nirantarabhāva), are conjoined with the mind from their arising until their dissolution; therefore those states are called cittasaṃsaṭṭhā, “conjoined with consciousness”.
中文:
有些法因为进入了无差别(nirantarabhāva)的状态,从生起到坏灭都与心混合在一起,所以这些法称为 cittasaṃsaṭṭhā(心相杂的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states, by coming into a state of being without interval, or: a state of being without distinction, are conjoined with the mind from their arising up to their dissolution; for that reason those states are called cittasaṃsaṭṭhā, “conjoined with consciousness”.
中文:
有些法因为进入了无间隔的状态,或者说:进入了无差别的状态,从生起开始直到坏灭都与心交融在一起,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 cittasaṃsaṭṭhā(心相杂的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states, even though they occur together (with the mind), do not come into a state of being without distinction, and so are not conjoined with the mind; therefore those states are called cittavisaṃsaṭṭhā, “not conjoined with consciousness”. [By api (“even though”) he implies: what need is there to speak of the not-coming-into-non-distinction of states that do not occur together with the mind at all?]
Note: Nirantarabhāvūpagamanatāya. When consciousness and the mental factors are conjoined, they become one, to such an extent that one cannot tell the distinct natures apart: “this is contact, this is feeling, this is consciousness”. It is like cooking the four sweets (catumadhu), where ghee, honey and the rest are mixed until they become one. The word nira here denotes distinction (bheda). That is why the Ṭīkā explains it as “dubbiññeyyanānatta” (“whose difference is hard to discern”). But when consciousness supports matter by conascence condition (sahajāta), they do not come into such a state of non-distinction; their difference in nature remains clear and evident.
中文:
有些法虽然(与心)一起生起,但没有进入无差别的状态,所以与心不相杂;因此这些法称为 cittavisaṃsaṭṭhā(心不相杂的)。[用 api(虽然)一词暗示:那些根本不与心一起生起的法,没有进入无差别状态就更不用说了。]
注:Nirantarabhāvūpagamanatāya。心和心所混合时,会合而为一,以至于无法分辨各自的特性:“这是触,这是受,这是心”。就像煮四甜(catumadhu)时,酥油、蜂蜜等混合到成为一体一样。这里的 nira 一词表示差别(bheda)。所以疏钞把它解释为“dubbiññeyyanānatta”(其差别难以辨识)。但是当心以俱生缘(sahajāta)之力帮助色时,它们并不进入这种无差别的状态,各自的特性差别仍然清楚明显。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states, even though they occur together with the mind, do not come into a state of being without interval, or: of not being other, and so are not conjoined with the mind; for that reason those states are called cittavisaṃsaṭṭhā, “not conjoined with consciousness”.
中文:
有些法虽然与心一起生起,但没有进入无间隔的状态,或者说:没有进入非异的状态,所以与心不相交融,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 cittavisaṃsaṭṭhā(心不相杂的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
[States] arise because of this (consciousness); therefore (because it is their cause of arising), it (that consciousness) is called samuṭṭhāna, “originating cause”.
中文:
[诸法]因为这(心)而生起,所以(因为它是生起的原因),它(那心)称为 samuṭṭhāna(等起因)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
[States] arise because of that consciousness; for that reason (because it is the cause of their arising), that consciousness is called samuṭṭhāna, “originating cause”.
中文:
[诸法]因为那个心而生起,因为这个缘故(因为它是生起的原因),那个心称为 samuṭṭhāna(等起因)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
These states have consciousness as their originating cause; therefore those states are called cittasamuṭṭhānā, “originated by consciousness”.
中文:
这些法以心为等起因,所以这些法称为 cittasamuṭṭhānā(心等起的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
These states have an originating cause called consciousness; for that reason those states are called cittasamuṭṭhānā, “originated by consciousness”.
中文:
这些法有称为心的等起因,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 cittasamuṭṭhānā(心等起的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states arise together (saha bhavanti); therefore those states are called sahabhuno, “coexistent”.
中文:
有些法一起生起(saha bhavanti),所以这些法称为 sahabhuno(俱有的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states arise together; for that reason those states are called sahabhuno, “coexistent”.
中文:
有些法一起生起,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 sahabhuno(俱有的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
States that are coexistent with consciousness are cittasahabhuno, “coexistent with consciousness”.
中文:
与心一起生起的法,就是 cittasahabhuno(心俱有的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states arise together with consciousness; for that reason those states are called cittasahabhuno, “coexistent with consciousness”.
中文:
有些法与心一起生起,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 cittasahabhuno(心俱有的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states occur following along (anuparivattanti); therefore those states are called anuparivattino, “following along”.
中文:
有些法随顺而转起(anuparivattanti),所以这些法称为 anuparivattino(随转的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states occur following along; for that reason those states are called anuparivattino, “following along”.
中文:
有些法随顺而转起,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 anuparivattino(随转的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
What do they follow along with? (This is the question.)
中文:
它们随顺什么而转起呢?(这是问题。)
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
What do they follow along with?
中文:
它们随顺什么而转起呢?
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Consciousness. (They follow along with consciousness. This is the answer.)
中文:
心。(它们随顺心而转起。这是回答。)
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Consciousness.
中文:
心。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
States that follow along with consciousness are cittānuparivattino, “following along with consciousness”.
中文:
随顺心而转起的法,就是 cittānuparivattino(随心转的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
They occur following along with consciousness. States that occur following along with consciousness are cittānuparivattino, “following along with consciousness”.
中文:
它们随顺心而转起。随顺心而转起的法,就是 cittānuparivattino(随心转的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
They are conjoined with consciousness, and they are originated by consciousness (they have consciousness as their originating cause). Because of these two capacities, they are called cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānā, “conjoined with and originated by consciousness”.
Note: What is meant is cittasaṃsaṭṭha-cittasamuṭṭhānā; the second word citta has been elided. The same applies in the following sentences.
中文:
它们既与心相杂,又是心等起的(以心为等起因)。因为这两种性能,所以称为 cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānā(心相杂等起的)。
注:本来要说的是 cittasaṃsaṭṭha-cittasamuṭṭhānā,第二个 citta 字被省略了。后面的句子也一样。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
They are conjoined with consciousness, and they are originated by consciousness. For that reason those states are called cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānā, “conjoined with and originated by consciousness”.
中文:
它们既与心交融,又以心为等起因。因为这个缘故,这些法称为 cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānā(心相杂等起的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
They are conjoined with consciousness, they are originated by consciousness, and they are indeed coexistent with consciousness. Because of these three capacities, they are called cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānasahabhuno, “conjoined with, originated by and coexistent with consciousness”.
Note: The word eva (“indeed”) is a restricting particle (avadhāraṇa) that makes their being coexistent with consciousness certain.
中文:
它们既与心相杂,又是心等起的,而且确实是与心俱有的。因为这三种性能,所以称为 cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānasahabhuno(心相杂等起俱有的)。
注:eva(确实)这个字是限定词(avadhāraṇa),使“与心俱有”这一点确定下来。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
They are conjoined with consciousness, they are originated by consciousness, and they arise only together with consciousness. Because of these three capacities, those states are called cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānasahabhuno.
中文:
它们既与心交融,又以心为等起因,而且只与心一起生起。因为这三种性能,这些法称为 cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānasahabhuno(心相杂等起俱有的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
They are conjoined with consciousness, they are originated by consciousness, and they indeed follow along with consciousness. Therefore they are called cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānānuparivattino, “conjoined with, originated by and following along with consciousness”.
中文:
它们既与心相杂,又是心等起的,而且确实是随心转的。所以称为 cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānānuparivattino(心相杂等起随转的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
They are conjoined with consciousness, they are originated by consciousness, and they only follow along with consciousness. For that reason those states are called cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānānuparivattino.
中文:
它们既与心交融,又以心为等起因,而且只随心转起。因为这个缘故,这些法称为 cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānānuparivattino(心相杂等起随转的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
All the remaining terms (such as no cittasamuṭṭhānā) should be understood by way of the negation of [the nature of] the terms already stated.
Note: The older nissaya reads “paṭipakkhavasena” (“by way of the opposite”). But since “ubhayasabhāvapaṭikkhepavasena” and so on have come up, beginning from the vipāka triad, the reading should be simply “paṭikkhepa”.
中文:
其余所有的词(如 no cittasamuṭṭhānā 等),都应以否定已说过的那些词[的性质]的方式来理解。
注:旧 nissaya 读作“paṭipakkhavasena”(以相反的方式)。但因为从异熟三法开始就出现过“ubhayasabhāvapaṭikkhepavasena”等说法,所以读法应该只是“paṭikkhepa”(否定)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
All the remaining terms, other than those already explained, should be understood by way of the opposite of the terms already explained.
Note: [Gloss:] “cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānādipadesu saṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānādisaddā cittasaddāpekkhāti paccekaṃ cittasaddasambandhattā cittasaṃsaṭṭhā ca te cittasamuṭṭhānā cāti paccekaṃ yojetvā attho vutto”: “In terms such as cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhāna, the words saṃsaṭṭha, samuṭṭhāna and so on depend on the word citta. Since each is connected with the word citta, the meaning was stated by joining each separately: ‘they are conjoined with consciousness and they are originated by consciousness’.” (Ṭīkā, p. 54)
中文:
除了已解释过的之外,其余所有的词,都应以已解释过的那些词的相反意义来理解。
注:[解释:]“cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānādipadesu saṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhānādisaddā cittasaddāpekkhāti paccekaṃ cittasaddasambandhattā cittasaṃsaṭṭhā ca te cittasamuṭṭhānā cāti paccekaṃ yojetvā attho vutto”:“在 cittasaṃsaṭṭhasamuṭṭhāna 等词中,saṃsaṭṭha、samuṭṭhāna 等词都依赖 citta 这个词。因为每一个都与 citta 一词相连,所以把它们一一分别结合起来说明意义:‘它们既与心相杂,又是心等起的’。”(疏钞,第 54 页)
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
With reference to the internal-internal (ajjhattajjhatta), and in the way stated in the internal triad (ajjhattattika), states that are internal are themselves ajjhattikā, “internal”.
Note: In the internal triad, the internal (ajjhattika) states were called “ajjhattajjhatta”. Look back at that passage.
中文:
就内之内(ajjhattajjhatta)而言,按照内三法(ajjhattattika)中所说的方式,内的法本身就是 ajjhattikā(内的)。
注:在内三法中,内的(ajjhattika)诸法被称为“ajjhattajjhatta”(内之内)。请回头参看那一段。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
With reference to the internal that is called internal, in the way already stated in the internal triad, only the six internal sense bases (ajjhattikāyatana), which are included in the personal internal (niyakajjhatta) taken as a whole, or: which occur as parts of the personal internal taken as a whole, are called ajjhattikā, “internal”.
中文:
就被称为“内”的内而言,按照内三法中已说过的方式,只有包含在整体的自身之内(niyakajjhatta)中的六内处(ajjhattikāyatana),或者说:作为整体的自身之内的组成部分而存在的六内处,才称为 ajjhattikā(内的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
States that exist outside those (six internal sense bases) are therefore called bāhirā, “external”.
中文:
存在于那(六内处)之外的法,所以称为 bāhirā(外的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
States that exist outside that internal continuity (ajjhattasantāna) are called bāhirā, “external”.
中文:
存在于那内的相续(ajjhattasantāna)之外的法,称为 bāhirā(外的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states only take hold of (only depend on) the great elements (bhūta); they are not themselves taken hold of the way the great elements are. Therefore those states are called upādā, “derived”.
Note: In the first upādiyanti the suffix ya is of the divādi class, expressing the agent (kattā). In the second it is the ya suffix expressing the object (kamma).
中文:
有些法只是执取(只是依止)大种(bhūta),它们本身不像大种那样被执取。所以这些法称为 upādā(所造的)。
注:第一个 upādiyanti 中的 ya 词缀属于 divādi 类,表示施事者(kattā);第二个则是表示受事(kamma)的 ya 词缀。
(From the footnote later)
English:
Upādā. It is the root dā with the prefixes upa and ā, and the agent suffix kvi. In “upādīyantīti upādā” only the agent form is the point. Because, according to the principle “sabbapadaṃ sāvadhāraṇaṃ” (“every word carries a restriction”), the sense of the word eva can be had from that agent form, when eva is added, an extra sentence comes out as what eva excludes: “na bhūtāni viya upādīyanti” (“they are not depended on the way the great elements are”). The point is: the 24 kinds of material phenomena called upādā only depend on the great elements. The great elements both depend and are depended on: one great element depends on the other three, and so on. Derived material phenomena are not depended on in that way. [This meaning is also shown, with a mnemonic verse, in the Saṅgaha Bhāsāṭīkā’s explanation of derived matter.]
中文:
Upādā。词根 dā 加前缀 upa、ā,加表施事的词缀 kvi。“upādīyantīti upādā”中,要点只在施事形式。依照“sabbapadaṃ sāvadhāraṇaṃ”(每个词都带有限定)的原则,从这个施事形式可以得到 eva(只是)的意义;加上 eva 之后,就多出一句作为 eva 所排除的内容:“na bhūtāni viya upādīyanti”(它们不像大种那样被依止)。意思是:称为 upādā 的二十四种色只是依止大种;而大种则既依止也被依止,例如一种大种依止其他三种大种等。所造色则不会那样被依止。[《摄论 Bhāsāṭīkā》在解释所造色时,也连同偈颂说明了这个意思。]
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states only cling to the great elements, only depend on them. Just as the great elements are clung to and depended on, so these states are not clung to and not depended on. For that reason those states are called upādā, “derived”.
Note: “atha vā bhūtāni amuñcitvā tesaṃ vaṇṇanibhādibhāvena gahetabbato upādā”: “Or else they are upādā because, without letting go of the great elements, they are to be taken as the colour, shine and so on of those elements.” This is the view of the Ṭīkā (p. 54).
中文:
有些法只是执着大种,只是依止大种。大种被执着、被依止;这些法却不被执着、不被依止。因为这个缘故,这些法称为 upādā(所造的)。
注:“atha vā bhūtāni amuñcitvā tesaṃ vaṇṇanibhādibhāvena gahetabbato upādā”:“或者,因为它们不离大种,应当作为那些大种的颜色、光泽等来理解,所以称为 upādā。”这是疏钞(第 54 页)的看法。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Those that are not merely taking hold (not merely depending) are noupādā, “not derived”. [The word eva limits it to depending.]
中文:
那些不只是执取(不只是依止)的法,就是 noupādā(非所造的)。[eva 这个字把它限定在“依止”上。]
(From the footnote later)
English:
Noupādā. By noupādā one gets consciousness, mental factors, the great elements and Nibbāna. Of these, consciousness, mental factors and Nibbāna do not depend on the four great elements at all; and although the great elements depend on one another, [one] cannot depend on all four. That is why it is glossed: “bhūtāni, the four great elements, na upādiyanteva, they do not take hold of [them], or: they do not depend on [them].” [The older nissaya, however, glosses: “they are not merely those that cling to and depend on [them]; they are also clung to and depended on.” Since consciousness, mental factors and Nibbāna are neither clung to nor depended on [in that way], consider that meaning carefully. In noupādā, no and upādā are two separate words; it is not the analysis of “na upādā”, but only shows the meaning.]
中文:
Noupādā。noupādā 包括心、心所、大种和涅槃。其中,心、心所、涅槃完全不依止四大种;大种虽然彼此依止,但[一种]不能依止全部四种。所以解释为:“bhūtāni(四大种),na upādiyanteva(它们不执取[它们]),或者:不依止[它们]。”[但旧 nissaya 解释为:“它们不只是执取、依止[大种]的,它们也被执取、被依止。”由于心、心所、涅槃并不[那样]被执取、被依止,所以请仔细思考那个意义。noupādā 中的 no 和 upādā 是两个词,它不是“na upādā”的分析,只是说明意义。]
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states are not merely those that cling to and depend on [the great elements]: they are also clung to and depended on. (Reverse it this way.) For that reason those states are called noupādā, “not derived”.
Note: The point is that both the agent sense and the object sense apply [to noupādā]. Upādā, however, has only the agent sense, not the object sense.
中文:
有些法不只是执着、依止[大种]的,它们也被执着、被依止。(要这样反过来理解。)因为这个缘故,这些法称为 noupādā(非所造的)。
注:意思是[noupādā]兼有施事和受事两种意义;而 upādā 只有施事义,没有受事义。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
In the clinging cluster (upādānagocchaka), the meaning should be understood like this: some states take hold [of an object] intensely (bhusaṃ ādiyanti); therefore those states are called upādānā, “clingings”. That is, they take hold in such a way that it counts as a firm grasp (daḷhaggāha). This is the meaning.
Note: To make known that the word upa here means “intensely” (bhusattha), upa is explained as bhusaṃ. And to make known that “intensely” means taking hold firmly, without being able to let go, it is explained as daḷhaggāhaṃ. That word daḷhaggāhaṃ is an adverb qualifying the verb.
中文:
在取组(upādānagocchaka)中,意义应这样理解:有些法强烈地执取[所缘](bhusaṃ ādiyanti),所以这些法称为 upādānā(取)。也就是说,它们执取到可以称为牢固执取(daḷhaggāha)的程度。这是它的意思。
注:为了让人知道 upa 这个字在这里表示“强烈”(bhusattha),所以把 upa 解释为 bhusaṃ。又为了让人知道“强烈”就是无法放开、牢固地执取,所以解释为 daḷhaggāhaṃ。daḷhaggāhaṃ 这个词是修饰动词的副词。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
In the clinging cluster: some states take hold [of objects] intensely, that is, they cling; for that reason those states are called upādānā, “clingings”. They grasp with a firm clinging. This is the meaning.
中文:
在取组中:有些法强烈地执取[所缘],也就是执着,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 upādānā(取)。它们以牢固的执着去执取。这就是它的意思。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
States other than those (clinging states) are called noupādānā, “not clingings”.
中文:
那些(取法)以外的其他法,称为 noupādānā(非取)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
States other than those clingings are not called clingings (noupādānā).
中文:
那些取以外的其他法,不称为取(noupādānā)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
In the defilement cluster (kilesagocchaka), the meaning should be understood only in the way stated in the defiled triad (saṃkiliṭṭhattika).
Note: Although it says “in the way stated”, there is still a difference: here the word saṃ is not included.
中文:
在烦恼组(kilesagocchaka)中,意义只应按照杂染三法(saṃkiliṭṭhattika)中所说的方式来理解。
注:虽然说“按照所说的方式”,但还是有所不同:这里没有 saṃ 这个字。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
In the defilement cluster, the meaning should be understood only in the way already stated in the defiled triad, namely, removing the word saṃ, “kilissantīti kilesā” (“they defile, therefore defilements”) and so on.
中文:
在烦恼组中,意义只应按照杂染三法中已说过的方式来理解,也就是去掉 saṃ 这个字,以“kilissantīti kilesā”(它们使染污,所以称为烦恼)等方式来理解。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
In the back dukas (piṭṭhiduka), the meaning should be understood like this: some states move about (avacaranti) in the sense sphere (kāma); therefore they are kāmāvacarā, “of the sense sphere”. Some move about in the fine-material sphere (rūpa); therefore they are rūpāvacarā, “of the fine-material sphere”.
中文:
在后二法(piṭṭhiduka)中,意义应这样理解:有些法运行(avacaranti)于欲界(kāma),所以称为 kāmāvacarā(欲界的);有些法运行于色界(rūpa),所以称为 rūpāvacarā(色界的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
In the back dukas: some states mostly (yebhuyyena) move about and occur in kāma, the sense-sphere existence, that is, the eleven sense-sphere planes; for that reason they are called kāmāvacarā. Some states mostly move about in rūpa, the fine-material existence, that is, the fifteen fine-material planes excluding the plane of non-percipient beings; for that reason they are called rūpāvacarā.
Note (Vacanattha, “word meaning”): “kāmataṇhā kāmo; kāmo avacarati ettha etesu dhammesu ārammaṇakaraṇavasenāti kāmāvacarā. rūpataṇhā rūpaṃ; rūpaṃ avacarati ettha ārammaṇakaraṇavasenāti rūpāvacarā. arūpataṇhā arūpaṃ; arūpaṃ avacarati ettha ārammaṇakaraṇavasenāti arūpāvacarā”: “Kāma is sense-sphere craving; kāma moves about in these states by taking them as object, therefore they are kāmāvacara. Rūpa is fine-material craving; rūpa moves about in them by taking them as object, therefore rūpāvacara. Arūpa is immaterial craving; arūpa moves about in them by taking them as object, therefore arūpāvacara.” (Ṭīkā, p. 55) [This note is attached under [21-26] in the Nissaya; it explains kāmāvacarā etc., so it is placed here.]
中文:
在后二法中:有些法大多(yebhuyyena)运行、生起于 kāma,即欲有,也就是十一欲界地,因为这个缘故,称为 kāmāvacarā(欲界的)。有些法大多运行于 rūpa,即色有,也就是除了无想有情天以外的十五色界地,因为这个缘故,称为 rūpāvacarā(色界的)。
注(Vacanattha,字义):“kāmataṇhā kāmo; kāmo avacarati ettha etesu dhammesu ārammaṇakaraṇavasenāti kāmāvacarā. rūpataṇhā rūpaṃ; rūpaṃ avacarati ettha ārammaṇakaraṇavasenāti rūpāvacarā. arūpataṇhā arūpaṃ; arūpaṃ avacarati ettha ārammaṇakaraṇavasenāti arūpāvacarā”:“欲界渴爱称为 kāma;kāma 以这些法为所缘而运行于其中,所以称为 kāmāvacara。色界渴爱称为 rūpa;rūpa 以它们为所缘而运行于其中,所以称为 rūpāvacara。无色界渴爱称为 arūpa;arūpa 以它们为所缘而运行于其中,所以称为 arūpāvacara。”(疏钞,第 55 页)[这条注在 nissaya 中附在 [21-26] 之下;因为它解释的是 kāmāvacarā 等,所以放在这里。]
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states move about in the immaterial sphere; therefore those states are called arūpāvacarā, “of the immaterial sphere”.
中文:
有些法运行于无色界,所以这些法称为 arūpāvacarā(无色界的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states mostly move about in arūpa, the immaterial existence, that is, the four immaterial planes; for that reason they are called arūpāvacarā.
中文:
有些法大多运行于 arūpa,即无色有,也就是四无色界地,因为这个缘故,称为 arūpāvacarā(无色界的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
This (what has been said) is the brief meaning here (in this explanation of the mātikā).
中文:
这(已说的)是这里(这段论母解释中)的简要意义。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
This (what has been said) is the summary here (in the back dukas).
中文:
这(已说的)是这里(后二法中)的摘要。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
But the detailed meaning will become clear later on.
Note: It will be explained at length in the explanation of “kāmāvacaraṃ kusalaṃ cittaṃ uppannaṃ”. The older nissaya, however, glosses: “yebhuyyena, for the most part; avacaranti, they move about, they occur”. That intention too will become clear later.
中文:
而详细的意义将在后面清楚地显示出来。
注:将在“kāmāvacaraṃ kusalaṃ cittaṃ uppannaṃ”(欲界善心生起)的解释中详细说明。不过旧 nissaya 解释为:“yebhuyyena,大多;avacaranti,运行、生起”。这个意思也会在后面清楚地显示出来。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
But the detail will become clear later on.
中文:
而详细内容将在后面清楚地显示出来。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states are included (pariyāpannā), that is, contained within (antogadhā), the round of the three planes (tebhūmakavaṭṭa); therefore they are called pariyāpannā, “included”.
中文:
有些法摄属于(pariyāpannā),也就是包含在(antogadhā)三界轮转(tebhūmakavaṭṭa)之中,所以这些法称为 pariyāpannā(所摄的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states are included in, contained within, the round of suffering in the three planes; for that reason those states are called pariyāpannā, “included”. (Another way:) Some states are pariyāpannā in the round of the three planes, that is, they are delimited and taken (paricchinditvā āpannā gahitā) by craving that does the delimiting (paricchedakāya taṇhāya); for that reason those states are called pariyāpannā.
Note: “Delimited and taken” means “included”; that is why he says antogadhā. Gloss: antogadhā, “they are those that are included”; iti ayaṃ, “this”; adhippāyo, “is the intended meaning”.
Note (Kyamtak): Lest one take it that the base (ādhāra) of “pariyāpannā antogadhā” could also be the supramundane, so that the supramundane too would be called pariyāpanna, he says “tebhūmakavaṭṭe”. Since the included status of mundane states is directly evident in the world, one should not look for a base called “the supramundane”. [In the Nissaya this note is attached under [21-26]; it explains pariyāpannā, so it is placed here.]
中文:
有些法摄属于、包含在三界的轮转之苦中,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 pariyāpannā(所摄的)。(另一种解释:)有些法在三界轮转中是 pariyāpannā,即被能作区分的渴爱(paricchedakāya taṇhāya)区分而取(paricchinditvā āpannā gahitā),因为这个缘故,这些法称为 pariyāpannā。
注:“被区分而取”意思就是“被包含”,所以说 antogadhā。解释:antogadhā,“它们是被包含的”;iti ayaṃ,“这”;adhippāyo,“是所要表达的意思”。
注(Kyamtak):为了避免有人以为“pariyāpannā antogadhā”的所依(ādhāra)也可以是出世间,因而出世间法也称为 pariyāpanna,所以说“tebhūmakavaṭṭe”(在三界轮转中)。世间法的“所摄”性质在世间是直接可见的,所以不应该去找一个称为“出世间”的所依。[在 nissaya 中这条注附在 [21-26] 之下;因为它解释的是 pariyāpannā,所以放在这里。]
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Those not included in that (round of the three planes) are called apariyāpannā, “not included”.
Note: The word pariyāpanna denotes being contained within (antogadha). For how only mundane states get the name pariyāpanna and supramundane states do not, see the Ṭīkā.
中文:
没有摄属于那(三界轮转)之中的法,称为 apariyāpannā(非所摄的)。
注:pariyāpanna 这个词表示“包含在内”(antogadha)。关于为什么只有世间法得到 pariyāpanna 这个名称,而出世间法得不到,请看疏钞。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states are not included in that round of the three planes; for that reason those states are called apariyāpannā, “not included”.
中文:
有些法没有摄属于那三界轮转之中,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 apariyāpannā(非所摄的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states, cutting off the root of the round (ignorance and craving) and taking Nibbāna as their object, go out (niyyanti) from the round (the prison of the round); therefore (because they go out from the prison of the round) those states are called niyyānikā, “leading out”.
Note: It is the root yā with the prefix ni and the suffix anīya; the ī of nī is shortened and the y becomes k.
中文:
有些法断除轮转的根本(无明和渴爱),以涅槃为所缘,从轮转(轮转的牢狱)中出离(niyyanti);所以(因为它们能从轮转的牢狱中出离)这些法称为 niyyānikā(出离的)。
注:词根 yā 加前缀 ni、词缀 anīya;nī 的 ī 变短音,y 变成 k。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states, cutting off the root of the round, ignorance and craving, and taking Nibbāna as their object, go out from the prison of the suffering of the round; for that reason those states are called niyyānikā, “leading out”.
Note: “anīyasaddo bahulaṃ kattuabhidhāyakoti vaṭṭacārakato niyyantīti niyyānīyā, nīkārassa rassattaṃ, yakārassa ca kakārattaṃ katvā niyyānikāti vuttaṃ” (Ṭīkā, p. 55). Gloss this Ṭīkā as: anīyasaddo, the word anīya; bahulādhikārato, because the word bahula is in force; kattuabhidhāyako, expresses the agent; hoti. Why? Because the grammars say “bahulaṃ kriyattāti ca, sabbattha vattate”: when bahula is carried over from the rule “bhāvakammesu tabbānīyā”, [anīya] can also, by bahula, express the agent, which widens its scope. Some Ṭīkā copies read “abahulaṃ”, i.e. abahulena, “rarely, it expresses the agent”. But since the Madhu and others explain it as bahulaṃ, bahulaṃ is the old reading. In “nīkārassa rassattaṃ”, one should take the nī of the suffix anīya, as in karaṇīyaṃ and so on, not the prefix nī. [In niyyānika the prefix is ni; in nīvaraṇa the prefix is nī; take them in order: pa, parā, ni, nī.] The Madhusāra’s statement “nīkārassāti nīupasaggassa” does not accord with the grammars.
“niyyānakaraṇasīlā vā niyyānikā” (Ṭīkā): or else, niyyānakaraṇasīlā, “those whose habit is to bring about going out from the prison of the round”; niyyānikā. On this Ṭīkā view, just as in “asūpabhakkhanasīlo āsūpiko” one takes asūpa as eating without curry, here one takes niyyāna as bringing about going out, and the meaning is a taddhita formation “having that as habit” (tassīla). Tassīla is of two kinds: taddhita tassīla and kita tassīla. “rukkhamūle vasanasīlo rukkhamūliko” and the like are taddhita tassīla; “bhikkhanasīlo, yācanasīlo bhikkhu” and the like are kita tassīla. Asūpabhakkhanasīlo: one whose habit is eating food without curry, āsūpiko; or: one whose habit is not eating curry; or: one whose habit is not eating curry. Some readings have “apūpabhakkhanasīlo āpūpiko”: one whose habit is eating cakes; or: one whose habit is not eating cakes. According to the Anuṭīkā’s “niyyānasīlā eva vā”, both kita tassīla and taddhita tassīla should be mentioned: or else, niyyānasīlā eva, “those whose habit is simply going out from the prison of the round”, niyyānikā. Taking the root yā with the prefix ni and the suffix anīya gives kita tassīla; taking the word niyyāna with the suffix ṇika gives taddhita tassīla.
中文:
有些法断除轮转的根本,即无明和渴爱,以涅槃为所缘,从轮转之苦的牢狱中出离,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 niyyānikā(出离的)。
注:“anīyasaddo bahulaṃ kattuabhidhāyakoti vaṭṭacārakato niyyantīti niyyānīyā, nīkārassa rassattaṃ, yakārassa ca kakārattaṃ katvā niyyānikāti vuttaṃ”(疏钞,第 55 页)。这段疏钞要这样解释:anīyasaddo,anīya 这个词;bahulādhikārato,因为 bahula(多)这个词在起作用;kattuabhidhāyako,表示施事者;hoti。为什么?因为语法书说“bahulaṃ kriyattāti ca, sabbattha vattate”:当 bahula 从“bhāvakammesu tabbānīyā”这条规则延续下来时,[anīya]依 bahula 也可以表示施事者,使它的适用范围扩大。有些疏钞抄本读作“abahulaṃ”,即 abahulena,“很少表示施事者”。但因为《Madhu》等解释为 bahulaṃ,所以 bahulaṃ 才是旧读法。“nīkārassa rassattaṃ”中,应该取 anīya 词缀的 nī,就像在 karaṇīyaṃ 等中那样,而不应该取前缀 nī。[niyyānika 的前缀是 ni,nīvaraṇa 的前缀是 nī;要按照 pa、parā、ni、nī 的次序来取。]《Madhusāra》说“nīkārassāti nīupasaggassa”,这与语法书不合。
“niyyānakaraṇasīlā vā niyyānikā”(疏钞):或者,niyyānakaraṇasīlā,“以促成从轮转牢狱中出离为习性的”;niyyānikā。依这个疏钞的看法,就像在“asūpabhakkhanasīlo āsūpiko”中把 asūpa 理解为吃不配菜的食物那样,这里把 niyyāna 理解为促成出离,意思是“以此为习性”(tassīla)的 taddhita 构词。tassīla 有两种:taddhita tassīla 和 kita tassīla。“rukkhamūle vasanasīlo rukkhamūliko”(以住在树下为习性者,称为树下住者)等是 taddhita tassīla;“bhikkhanasīlo, yācanasīlo bhikkhu”(以乞求为习性者,称为比丘)等是 kita tassīla。asūpabhakkhanasīlo:以吃不配菜的食物为习性的人,āsūpiko;或者:以不吃菜为习性的人;或者:不以吃菜为习性的人。有些读法是“apūpabhakkhanasīlo āpūpiko”:以吃糕饼为习性的人;或者:不以吃糕饼为习性的人。依随疏钞“niyyānasīlā eva vā”的看法,应该说 kita tassīla 和 taddhita tassīla 两种:或者,niyyānasīlā eva,“只是以从轮转牢狱中出离为习性的”,niyyānikā。取词根 yā 加前缀 ni、词缀 anīya,就是 kita tassīla;取 niyyāna 这个词加词缀 ṇika,就是 taddhita tassīla。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states, by this characteristic (cutting off the root of the round and taking Nibbāna as object), do not go out (from the round), that is, do not go out from the prison of the round; therefore those states are called aniyyānikā, “not leading out”.
中文:
有些法不以这个特相(断除轮转的根本、以涅槃为所缘)而(从轮转中)出离,也就是不能从轮转的牢狱中出离;所以这些法称为 aniyyānikā(不出离的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states do not go out from the round by this characteristic already stated, “cutting off the root of the round” and so on; for that reason those states are called aniyyānikā, “not leading out”.
中文:
有些法不以前面所说的“断除轮转的根本”等这个特相从轮转中出离,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 aniyyānikā(不出离的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Because they are fixed (niyata) in giving their result immediately after death, or immediately after their own occurrence, they are niyatā, “fixed”.
Note: “Immediately after death” refers to fixed wrong view (niyatamicchādiṭṭhi) and the five deeds with immediate result (pañcānantariya). “Immediately after their own occurrence” refers to the path.
中文:
因为它们在死亡之后紧接着、或者在自己生起之后紧接着给予果报这一点上是确定的(niyata),所以称为 niyatā(决定的)。
注:“死亡之后紧接着”指的是决定邪见(niyatamicchādiṭṭhi)和五无间业(pañcānantariya);“自己生起之后紧接着”指的是道。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Because they are fixed in giving their result immediately after death, or immediately after their own occurrence, they are niyatā, “fixed”.
中文:
因为它们在死亡之后紧接着、或者在自己生起之后紧接着给予果报这一点上是确定的,所以称为 niyatā(决定的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Because in that way (giving their result immediately after death, or immediately after themselves) they are not fixed, they are aniyatā, “not fixed”.
中文:
因为在那个方式上(在死亡之后紧接着、或在自身之后紧接着给予果报)它们不是确定的,所以称为 aniyatā(不定的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Because they are not fixed in that mode of giving their result immediately after death or immediately after themselves, they are aniyatā, “not fixed”.
中文:
因为在“死亡之后紧接着或自身之后紧接着给予果报”这一点上不是确定的,所以称为 aniyatā(不定的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states pass beyond (uttaranti), that is, abandon (pajahanti), other states (mundane states other than themselves); therefore those states are called uttarā, “surpassing”.
中文:
有些法超越(uttaranti),也就是舍弃(pajahanti)其他的法(自身以外的世间法),所以这些法称为 uttarā(超越的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states pass beyond, that is, abandon, only other states; for that reason those states are called uttarā, “surpassing”.
中文:
有些法超越,也就是舍弃只是其他的法,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 uttarā(超越的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states exist together with surpassing states (uttarā) that are able to pass beyond them (the states that have something surpassing them); therefore those states are called sauttarā, “surpassable”.
Note: Sauttarā. The root tara with the prefix u denotes “passing beyond”. And to make known that “passing beyond” here is not going beyond to somewhere else, but passing beyond by abandoning mundane states, he explains it as “pajahanti”. By uttara one gets the supramundane states. By sauttarā, however, one gets the mundane states, which exist together with such states able to pass beyond them (which have states able to pass beyond them) and so are passed beyond. That is why the object of uttarituṃ is supplied as “attānaṃ” (“themselves”). [In the Bhāsāṭīkā this note is attached under [89-100]; it explains sauttarā, so it is placed here.]
中文:
有些法与能超越它们的超越法(uttarā)同在(即有能超越它们的法),所以这些法称为 sauttarā(有上的、可被超越的)。
注:Sauttarā。词根 tara 加前缀 u,表示“超越”。而为了让人知道这里的“超越”不是越过去到别处,而是以舍弃世间法的方式来超越,所以解释为“pajahanti”(舍弃)。用 uttara 得到的是出世间法;用 sauttarā 得到的则是与那种能超越的法同在(有能超越它们的法)、因而被超越的世间法。所以要补上 uttarituṃ 的宾语“attānaṃ”(自身)。[在 Bhāsāṭīkā 中这条注附在 [89-100] 之下;因为它解释的是 sauttarā,所以放在这里。]
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states exist together with surpassing states that are able to abandon, or pass beyond, them; for that reason those states are called sauttarā, “surpassable”.
中文:
有些法与能舍弃、能超越它们的超越法同在,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 sauttarā(有上的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
These (supramundane states) have no states surpassing them (states that pass beyond them, or that can abandon them); therefore those states are called anuttarā, “unsurpassed”.
中文:
这些(出世间法)没有超越它们的法(能超越它们、或能舍弃它们的法),所以这些法称为 anuttarā(无上的)。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
These states have no states able to abandon or pass beyond them; for that reason those states are called anuttarā, “unsurpassed”.
中文:
这些法没有能舍弃、能超越它们的法,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 anuttarā(无上的)。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Beings weep (raṇanti) because of these states; therefore those states are called raṇā, “causes of conflict (lamentation)”. This word raṇa is a designation for those states, lust and the rest, overcome by which beings weep and lament in various ways.
Note: Raṇā. The root raṇa denotes sound (sadda) and going (gati). Here, to make known the meaning of making sound, he explains raṇanti as “kandanti”. And since the root kanda too denotes weeping, calling and crying out, to take the meaning of weeping here he explains it as “paridevanti”: making sound by weeping. Although weeping concerns all the unwholesome consciousness that causes weeping, he wants only lust, delusion and so on to be taken by raṇa, so he says “rāgādīnaṃ … adhivacanaṃ”. In rāgādīnaṃ, by ādi take only hate and delusion according to the Aṭṭhakathā; the Ṭīkā takes all the defilements.
中文:
众生因为这些法而哭泣(raṇanti),所以这些法称为 raṇā(诤,即哀泣之因)。raṇa 这个词,是对贪等那些法的称呼:众生被它们所压倒,就以种种方式哭泣、悲叹。
注:Raṇā。词根 raṇa 表示发声(sadda)和行走(gati)。这里为了让人知道是“发声”的意思,把 raṇanti 解释为“kandanti”(哭喊)。而词根 kanda 也表示哭泣、呼唤、喊叫,这里为了取“哭泣”的意思,又解释为“paridevanti”(悲叹):以哭泣的方式发声。虽然哭泣与所有导致哭泣的不善心都有关,但只想用 raṇa 来指贪、痴等,所以说“rāgādīnaṃ … adhivacanaṃ”(贪等的称呼)。rāgādīnaṃ 中,依义注,ādi(等)只包括瞋和痴;疏钞则包括一切烦恼。
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Beings weep and lament because of these states, lust and so on; for that reason (because they are the cause of weeping and lamenting) those states, lust and so on, are called raṇā. This name raṇa is the name of those states, lust and so on, overcome by which beings weep and lament in various ways.
中文:
众生因为贪等这些法而哭泣悲叹,因为这个缘故(因为它们是哭泣悲叹的原因),贪等这些法称为 raṇā(诤)。raṇa 这个名称,是贪等那些法的名称:众生被它们所压倒,就以种种方式哭泣悲叹。
【Bhāsāṭīkā ဘာသာဋီကာ】
English:
Some states, by way of association (sampayoga) and by way of being abandoned at one stroke (pahānekaṭṭhatā), exist together with causes of conflict; therefore those states are called saraṇā, “with conflict”.
中文:
有些法以相应(sampayoga)的方式,以及以同一舍断(pahānekaṭṭhatā)的方式,与诤同在,所以这些法称为 saraṇā(有诤的)。
(From the footnote later; found in 96:890 [16-25])
English:
Saraṇā. In “states with raṇa, that is, with lust, hate and delusion”, by way of association one gets the greed-rooted consciousness that is with lust, the hate-rooted consciousness that is with hate, and the unwholesome consciousness that is with delusion. [The meaning of pahānekaṭṭha has been shown in the Ṭīkā.]
中文:
Saraṇā(有诤的)。在“与称为 raṇa 的贪、瞋、痴同在的法”中,以相应的方式,可以得到与贪同在的贪根心、与瞋同在的瞋根心、与痴同在的不善心。[pahānekaṭṭha(同一舍断)的意思已在疏钞中说明。]
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
Some states, by way of association and by way of being abandoned at one stroke, occur together with the causes of weeping, lust and so on; for that reason those states are called saraṇā, “with conflict”.
Note (Vacanattha): “pahānavasena ekasmiṃ puggale tiṭṭhantīti pahānekaṭṭhā; pahānekaṭṭhānaṃ bhāvo pahānekaṭṭhatā; pahānekaṭṭhatāya vaso āyatto pahānekaṭṭhatāvaso” (Yojanā, p. 74): “they stand in one person in respect of abandoning, therefore pahānekaṭṭha; the state of these is pahānekaṭṭhatā; dependence on that is pahānekaṭṭhatāvasa.” By way of association, take the thirteen unwholesome mental factors other than the nine defilements; by way of being abandoned at one stroke, take only hate and delusion. The Ṭīkā teacher, however, also proposes three further interpretations: (1) in “raṇohatā na jotanti candasūriyā satārakā” (“overcome by dust, the moon and sun with the stars do not shine”), raṇa is a synonym of reṇu (“dust”), so “saha raṇehi rāgādireṇūhīti saraṇā”, “together with the dust of lust and so on, therefore saraṇa”; (2) in “saraṇaṃ katvā nikkhami” (“having made war, he went out”), raṇa is a synonym of yuddha (“battle”), so “saha raṇena ariyamaggayuddhenāti saraṇā”, “together with the battle of the noble path, therefore saraṇa”; (3) in the Araṇavibhaṅga Sutta, the results of the unwholesome, suffering, vexation, despair and fever, are called raṇa, so “saha raṇehi phalabhūtehi dukkhavighātaupāyāsapariḷāhehīti saraṇā”, “together with the resulting suffering, vexation, despair and fever, therefore saraṇa”. [This note is attached under [108-113] in the Nissaya; it explains saraṇā and pahānekaṭṭhatā, so it is placed here.]
中文:
有些法以相应的方式,以及以同一舍断的方式,与贪等哭泣之因一起生起,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 saraṇā(有诤的)。
注(Vacanattha,字义):“pahānavasena ekasmiṃ puggale tiṭṭhantīti pahānekaṭṭhā; pahānekaṭṭhānaṃ bhāvo pahānekaṭṭhatā; pahānekaṭṭhatāya vaso āyatto pahānekaṭṭhatāvaso”(《Yojanā》,第 74 页):“就舍断而言,它们住在同一个人身上,所以称为 pahānekaṭṭha(同一舍断);它们的状态是 pahānekaṭṭhatā;依于此,称为 pahānekaṭṭhatāvasa。”以相应的方式,取九种烦恼以外的十三种不善心所;以同一舍断的方式,只取瞋和痴。不过疏钞作者还另外提出三种解释:(1)在“raṇohatā na jotanti candasūriyā satārakā”(被尘埃遮蔽,日月和星星都不放光)中,raṇa 是 reṇu(尘埃)的同义词,所以“saha raṇehi rāgādireṇūhīti saraṇā”:与贪等尘埃同在,所以称为 saraṇa;(2)在“saraṇaṃ katvā nikkhami”(开战之后出去)中,raṇa 是 yuddha(战斗)的同义词,所以“saha raṇena ariyamaggayuddhenāti saraṇā”:与圣道之战同在,所以称为 saraṇa;(3)在《无诤分别经》(Araṇavibhaṅga Sutta)中,不善的果报,即苦、恼、忧、热恼,被称为 raṇa,所以“saha raṇehi phalabhūtehi dukkhavighātaupāyāsapariḷāhehīti saraṇā”:与作为果报的苦、恼、忧、热恼同在,所以称为 saraṇa。[在 nissaya 中这条注附在 [108-113] 之下;因为它解释的是 saraṇā 和 pahānekaṭṭhatā,所以放在这里。]
【Nissaya နိဿယ】
English:
These states do not have causes of weeping, lust and so on, in that mode already stated, association and being abandoned at one stroke; for that reason those states are called araṇā, “without conflict”.
中文:
这些法没有以前面所说的相应、同一舍断的方式而有的哭泣之因,即贪等,因为这个缘故,这些法称为 araṇā(无诤的)。